Safe Auto Insurance Company's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Safe Auto Insurance Company

1.1

About this business

The company offers auto, motorcycle, renters, and health insurance. 

Location details

4 Easton Oval, Columbus, OH, 43219, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Tue8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Wed8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Thu8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Fri8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Sat8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Sun8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
1.1396 reviews
Select a rating
Michael R.'s profile image
Michael R. 
2 years ago

Worst insurance company in history. They are crooks. When I was financing my truck it took multiple times to get them to send the finance company proof of insurance, and they kept getting the information wrong. Fast forward I'm financing a car now. I was told multiple times that the latest I can make my payment was the tenth. I went to pay it on the 9th in which we paid on the 9th multiple times only to see they canceled my insurance. I spoke to a supervisor over the matter but that didn't help. I paid almost 300 for my insu... read more

Tanisha M's profile image
Tanisha M 
2 years ago

I paid for auto insurance and the very next day canceled it. I called for my payment to be returned to my payment card and was told it would be a cancellation fee. I was not told of any cancellation fee the day before when I ordered it. My paperwork that I was supposed to sign wasnt even sent to me yet. Because it literally wasnt even 24hrs before I canceled. So legally I was not insured yet. I shouldnt be charged a cancellation fee that I wasnt told about at the time of my purchase. This is bad business. Its very upsetting ... read more

Tina E's profile image
Tina E 
2 years ago

I called for a tow for my car that was broke down in the middle of the street I called them for a tow the tow took for ever to come so the police tow my car and took it to the impound the people that was suppose to tow my car for safe auto was the people who tow my car for the police when I called to talk to them they try to be like its nothin they can do like Im upset for me to be paying a lot for this insurance they should be more better than that 

A.'s profile image
2 years ago

Absolutely horrible!! A total nightmare. I filed a claim after hitting a deer. Immediately there were issues. They didn't want to pay for repairs, they tried putting me in a 2 door compact car as a rental (I drive a 7 passenger SUV). They didn't want to pay for anything they are required to and tried to switch from repairing to totaling my vehicle after repairs had begun. It's been a month and I still do not have my car back. When I tried cancelling my policy after switching to a better insurance I was told it's not possible... read more

Nathaniel S's profile image
Nathaniel S 
2 years ago

This is the worst insurance company, or any company, that I have ever experienced. My car has been at the shop for 6 weeks and an adjuster has failed to estimate damages to the car. My rental car coverage policy has now lapsed and now I will be liable for payments on the rental car while there is no clear repair date in site to my vehicles vandalism damages. The company does not have their own adjusters and they have failed to get a third party to take a look at my car. There is no end in site. I would give them 0 stars if I... read more

Pattyrisha's profile image
Pattyrisha 
3 years ago

My car was hit while I was in the hospital for 3 days after calling Safe Auto and starting a claim I was told I would be sent a text message and that I would need to upload pictures I tried and open the text message and it had me take pictures and I had to adjust my phone to where the whole car fit in the picture after a couple pictures my data ran out so I told the gentleman on the phone and he said no worries they would send out an adjuster out to physically View it and write it up. The next day Instead of any adjuster com... read more

Eleanor S.'s profile image
Eleanor S. 
3 years ago

So I had SafeAuto when I owned my Camaro in 2017 and totaled it. They were an awesome company.When I went looking for auto insurance just two months ago, I decided to try them again. Rates looked great, went through everything, thought everything was fine. I got an email that stated something was changed on my policy. Attempted to go to the document on the website, website won't work. Called them and was told their website was down and they told me nothing had changed and I was paying the original rate. So for two months I p... read more

Eleanor S's profile image
Eleanor S 
3 years ago

So I had SafeAuto when I owned my Camaro in 2017 and totaled it. They were an awesome company.When I went looking for auto insurance just two months ago, I decided to try them again. Rates looked great, went through everything, thought everything was fine. I got an email that stated something was changed on my policy. Attempted to go to the document on the website, website won't work. Called them and was told their website was down and they told me nothing had changed and I was paying the original rate. So for two months I p... read more

a really fed up customer's profile image
a really fed up customer 
3 years ago

There are always error messages when you try to sign in. Today 10/13 I decided to call customer service again and ask him for some help and after being on the phone with them for five minutes I'm told all we have trouble with our app. Well if you have trouble with your app then get rid of it as I surely will be doing so with your insurance company before my expiration date 

Frequently asked questions about Safe Auto Insurance Company

How is Safe Auto Insurance Company rated?

Safe Auto Insurance Company has a 1.1 star rating with 396 reviews. 

When is Safe Auto Insurance Company open?

Safe Auto Insurance Company is closed now. It will open at 8:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com