American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida

1.5

About this business

Location details

5426 Bay Center Dr STE 650, Tampa, FL, 33609, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Tue8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Wed8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Thu8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Fri8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
1.574 reviews
Select a rating
Michael B's profile image
Michael B 
5 years ago

Price increases for second year of 1 year old house for unknown reason. 

Brandon P's profile image
Brandon P 
5 years ago

August 2019 storms came through and caused my roof to leak. Filed a claim and had an adjuster out within a week or so, which made me feel pretty decent with the speed it was going. After that virtual radio silence, emails, phone calls, messages left without answer. The hand full of times I did actually get a response it was just empty promises of progress on the claim. Now today, *********, I still have an open claim with zero faith that it will be decided on anytime soon. I would pay double the rates just to have this compa... read more

Patricia C's profile image
Patricia C 
5 years ago

MY RATING IS ZERO. Denying claims is what they do. In my case, their adjuster TW came to my home, took pictures of the storm damage, referred me to a couple of roofing companies for quotes. A couple of weeks later, I received a denial letter and a cancellation of my coverage.This is obviously a company with a culture of automatic denials as a rule. They will not only deny your claims, but also inflict financial damage on client like me that have paid them for many years and never had a claim . You woudl think that the Insura... read more

Business response:

Because this claim in litigation, we are unable to respond to this complaint. Our team will remain in touch with the insured's counsel. Thank you. 

Kimberly R's profile image
Kimberly R 
5 years ago

We have had many issues w/this company. We filed a claim because we had a leak in our bathroom which damaged our floors in the bathroom - the walls, etc. We had a water restoration company come out to dry out the bathroom. The claims adjuster advised me that I needed to cancel them because they were going to charge "them" a lot of money. They dried out the bathroom for a few days and when I advised them that I needed to cancel their service, they took out their equipment and left. The company stripped the running boards off ... read more

Business response:

Mrs. *******, We are currently working to resolve damages related to these two separate claims for water damage. We expect to resolve this matter within two weeks and will provide an update to you as soon as possible. Thank you. 

Dave's profile image
Dave 
5 years ago

Absolutely terrible customer service, no return calls, always tell you they're gonna email a supervisor and alert them of issues. Save yourself the aggravation and pay a little more and go with a different company. This company is horrible to deal with, that is if anybody will talk to you once you an issue. They're pathetic... 

Tommy D's profile image
Tommy D 
5 years ago

I'm not even a customer but I feel like this still fits here on Thursday, February 6 my car was crushed by a tree that fell off of one of their customers properties as I've dealt with the same type of situation before I know that I am entitled to the information such as the claim number and when an adjuster would be out to see my vehicle for the damages however American integrity tells me that they cannot give me any of that information without the customers express permission I know for a fact that I am 100% entitled to thi... read more

Business response:

Mr. ***, We are obligated to protect our policyholder's personal information. The decision to open a claim, and share information, must be initiated by the policyholder. Thank you. 

Annette D's profile image
Annette D 
5 years ago

Awful to work with no communication no call backs cheapest claims 

DIANA N's profile image
DIANA N 
5 years ago

Good Luck!, on getting a return call. I got denied but can't get a denial letter. 

Business response:

Hi *****, your adjuster, Tammy, said she spoke to with you on 11/08/19 and sent you a coverage decision letter by email on 11/11/19. If you have any other questions, please let us know. Thank you. 

Bob M's profile image
Bob M 
5 years ago

I am trying to settle a 2019 Hurricane Dorian damage claim with American integrity insurance company. All I get is stalling and delays They don't return phone calls or emails. I am going to have to get an attorney and go to Florida mediation. This time I got quotes three from roofing companies for my 2019 claim and sent them to American integrity. All the three other roofing companies repair quotes for my roof all came in around $6995, $6900 and the third one is $7395 So far very little or no response I had a problem with... read more

Frequently asked questions about American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida

How is American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida rated?

American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida has a 1.5 star rating with 74 reviews. 

When is American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida open?

American Integrity Insurance Company of Florida is open now. It will close at 5:30 p.m.  

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com