Plato's Closet's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Plato's Closet

3.2

About this business

We buy and sell gently used brand name clothing & accessories for teens and twenty-somethings. Plato's Closet® is the preferred store of fashion conscious, spending savvy teens and twenty-something's. We buy and sell gently used brand name apparel and accessories. Plato's Closet® puts cash in your pocket and offers cool stuff at great prices. Sell your clothes for cash on the spot. No appointment necessary. We buy all seasons, all day, every day. We make selling your items convenient and fun. 

Location details

7830 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI, 53717, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
3.2303 reviews
Select a rating
Abby Strohfeldt's profile image
Abby Strohfeldt 
8 years ago

Awesome selection of clothing and very fair prices for selling and purchasing clothes! I sold some items before I left for school: parted with some items I liked but knew someone else would love. Also, it is hard for me to go to both Plato's Closet locations and not find new items I love. 

Business response:

Thanks, Abby, for such a great review. We can only sell what we are able to purchase from our customers. So, a big thanks for parting with your clothing and making other customers happy about our selection. 

Karie Ann-b's profile image
Karie Ann-b 
8 years ago

I wish I had listened to other reviewers. Please listen to them. This place is a complete waste of your time. 

Business response:

Karie, we are sorry that you were unhappy with your experience. We must select our inventory based on the current styles that sell well for us, that are in great condition and that we need in our inventory. Unfortunately, we occassionally disappoint some customers when we are not able to purchase their clothing, shoes, handbags and other accessories, or when our computerized franchise pricing system sets our offer price at less than what our customers had hoped. We hope you will give us another chance. 

Callie Van Lare's profile image
Callie Van Lare 
8 years ago

Had many negative experiences here. Haven't gone back and never will. Waste of time. The employees are so rude and unpleasant. 

Kasey Bell's profile image
Kasey Bell 
8 years ago

Fuck Plato's Fuck Plato's Fuck Plato's Fuck Plato's Fuck Plato's 

Kelsey Rylatt's profile image
Kelsey Rylatt 
8 years ago

Hi! I visited your store on Zeier Road on Saturday, and wanted to let you know how thrilled I was with my experience! I bought and sold clothes on this trip and I was more than pleasantly surprised with my experience! The store was clean and the staff were amazing! I just wanted to let you know because this is the best Plato's Closet I've ever been to! Tell this store to keep up the good work!! 

Business response:

Thank you so much, Kelsey! It is always rewarding to hear when a customer has a good experience and likes our store. We do have a great team! Hope to meet you when you return. ~Diane (owner) 

Kailey Grace Kowalski's profile image
Kailey Grace Kowalski 
8 years ago

amazing!! love the fact that you can sell your old clothes. 

Business response:

Thank you, Kailey, for taking the time to let us know you like our store and for the 5-star review. We do our best to reach out to our customers to sell us their gently-used current style clothing and accessories so that we can offer fantastic merchandise to our buying customers. Thank you for helping us fill our racks with great style! Hope you stop in again, soon. ~Diane (Owner) 

Ouac Madison's profile image
Ouac Madison 
8 years ago

An excellent place to find great deals on clothes. 

Naee Miller's profile image
Naee Miller 
8 years ago

They Would Never Get My Support Again My Clothes Is Very Expensive And I Refuse Too Accept 8$ For 200$ Dollar Items No Way . These People Take Your Clothes For Their Own Price And Put them Up For Sell As If Their From a Real Clothing Store Selling Your Own Items For 40 ,50,60$$ And Only Give The Seller 20 Dollars Maybe Even that More Like 5 $ This Company Should Be All Types Of Shame Of Themselves Ripping Folks Outta They Cash Sorry Selves Poooooorr #Service Do Better Plato's closet..... 

Business response:

Naee, we typically offer about 30 - 40% of what we sell the items for. Customers receive a higher percentage for higher priced items. The merchandise is priced to sell between 50 to 70% off of mall prices. We explain our pricing in our advertising, on our printed materials and during the check-in and check-out process. We are a resale franchise business and our pricing is based on the franchise computer pricing. For example, if you bring in a pair of aeropostle jeans, we use our computer to select "denim" and "aeropostle", a... read more

Kayle Aileen Goodman's profile image
Kayle Aileen Goodman 
9 years ago

They've got a huge selection of PINK clothing! I would like the clothing on the walls to be a little more organized. I only found 1 shirt my size and it was mixed in with all of the other sizes...Cashier was very kind and lovely! I got 4 things for the price of 1 (new), maybe even cheaper than the price of 1. 

Business response:

Kayle, thank you for taking the time to give us much valued feedback. It sounds like sizing and colorizing is a task that we need to move to the top of our priority list. Your comment helps our team to realized that customers appreciate both the value pricing we offer and an organized shopping environment. We will work harder to live up to your and other customers' expectations! We are glad to know that your personal interaction with our sales associate was so positive. Stop in again, soon! 

Frequently asked questions about Plato's Closet

How is Plato's Closet rated?

Plato's Closet has a 3.2 star rating with 303 reviews. 

When is Plato's Closet open?

Plato's Closet is open now. It will close at 6:00 p.m.  

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com