Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

4.8

About this business

Location details

1031 E 54TH St, Indianapolis, IN, 46220, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
MonClosed
Tue5:00 p.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Wed5:00 p.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Thu5:00 p.m. to 9:30 p.m.
Fri5:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m.
Sat5:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m.
SunClosed
4.8396 reviews
Select a rating
Sherry Cherry Feeney's profile image
Sherry Cherry Feeney 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

Been going there since 1997, always a wonderful experience. Love everything about the place❤️ 

Cindy Swanson Williams's profile image
Cindy Swanson Williams 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

Great atmosphere, delicious food and reasonable prices. 

Business response:

Thank you Cindy! 

Don Pence III's profile image
Don Pence III 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

It’s a standard staple for Indy. Always great food great service friendly service and staff and you can’t help but love it 

Business response:

Thank you Don! 

Keaton Pitner's profile image
Keaton Pitner 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

Best Italian food in the city,fantastic service 

Business response:

Thank you Keaton! 

Jennifer Knoska Pollitt's profile image
Jennifer Knoska Pollitt 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

Wonderful food.woukd definitely recommend 

Business response:

Thank you Jennifer! 

Robert Sanborn's profile image
Robert Sanborn 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

terrific food and a nice selection of wine to go with it. have always enjoyed what we have. 

Business response:

Thank you Robert! 

Catie O'Flynn's profile image
Catie O'Flynn 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

We love eating here! For the price and experience this place is top notch. The best Italian in the city. Willing to wait an hour or more to dine here. It’s worth it! 

Vikki Nelson Hornak's profile image
Vikki Nelson Hornak 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

Beautiful night to sit out front and enjoy a glass of wine while waiting for our table. Food as always was wonderful. Well worth the hour wait lol 

Business response:

Thanks for coming in Vikki! 

Randal Hayes's profile image
Randal Hayes 
recommend  Recommended
4 years ago

worth the wait! Food is great and the atmosphere is beautiful. 

Frequently asked questions about Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

How is Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant rated?

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant has a 4.8 star rating with 396 reviews. 

When is Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant open?

Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant is closed now. It will open at 5:00 p.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com