Stewart Peter Steak House

markalanh 

on Citysearch

18 years ago

VERY DISSAPOINTING – Our family has been going to Luger's for years. Sometimes we pay cash and sometimes we use the PETER LUGERS credit card. It is very sad to see the way the food is trending downhill against all the other steakhouses that have recently arrived in the NY area. Example: order a steak one way it comes out another and they argue with you. NOT GOOD; although they finally agreed it was not close to what was ordered. They did replace it a bit later. Have to think about going back there. Very sad about this GREAT ... read more

drlisadds 

on Citysearch

19 years ago

An incredible experience!!! – This was one of the best restaurant experiences we've ever had! It was well worth the drive and the wait. The drinks at the bar are fabulous, and super strong! We're a young Manhattan couple, and we had so much fun. The food was incredible, we had the tomatoes, and the bacon, the steak, and the lobster, the veggies, and finished off with coffee. Couldn't have been better. Our waiter, Joe, was absolutely fantastic, courteous and friendly. It was very expensive, but well worth it. We'll definitely... read more

svantico 

on Citysearch

20 years ago

Overrated and Overpriced – Thank goodness we were guests of someone who treated us. Sure this place is famous, but be prepared to part with some serious cash to eat here. I can think of plenty of other places to enjoy a great steak across the country without plunking down your kid's college fund for a dinner. 

barb1022 

on Citysearch

20 years ago

Don't believe the hype..... – And here I thought I was going to have the "best" steak in the whole world! WOW, what a dissapointment! The only good thing about the restaurant is their waitstaff, very exceptional, there are about 4-5 waiters/busboys for each table. Please, heed my warning, do not go, save your money and grill your steak at home, you will enjoy it much better. 

linky 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Defiantely Over-Rated – I had high expectations for Peter Luger. After having top notch experiences at Ruths Chris and Old Homestead I was ready for a delicious steak. The menu was disappointing as there is only one selection of steak. Cooking a steak is very important. Rare means a cold center. Medium rare means a pink cool center. After ordering steaks accordingly at other steak houses I ordered medium rare at Peter Luger. The steak came out and it was most definitely medium. It was also VERY small when compared to Ruths C... read more

gsp209 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Good steak – I've never had better steak outside of Peter Luger. The steak and the juices and their sauce was a good combination. I also recommend getting the tomatos and Peter Luger sauce appetizer. It's a bit pricy for the appetizer, but it tastes really good. I think everyone should head out to Peter Luger at least once to try good steak.