Birdeye Logo White 2020
Watch Demo

New York Prime

Claim this profile

This business is unclaimed. Owners who claim this profile can update information, boost SEO, and more.

Claim this business for free
55 reviews
|Bars|Atlanta, GA 30326 United States

3424 Peachtree Rd NE, Ste 100, Atlanta, GA 30326 United States

(404) 846-0644

Closed now


Suggest edits
Top Restaurants in your area
(4) · Barbeque

5128 N Henry Blvd

(678) 759-1006
(7) · Restaurants

3109 Piedmont Rd NE

(404) 262-7379
(333) · Restaurants

1468 Mecaslin St NW

(404) 504-9044
(170) · Restaurants

2987 Main St NW building b

(770) 476-2202
(226) · American

3909 Steve Tate Hwy

(770) 893-3389
(11) · Restaurants

6320 Sugarloaf Pkwy

(678) 218-0800

Located at the Monarch Tower, one of the two buildings which make up the Monarch Centre, New York Prime offers you USDA prime cuts, guaranteed to satisfy your taste buds. The menu features appetizers like stone crabs, baked shrimp and oysters, which serve as a prelude to the fabulous steaks to come. The high quality ensures that nothing on the menu is inexpensive, but it's hard to mind shelling out the required money for a Petite New York Steak that's so delicious. The restaurant is available for private hire too.

Suggest edits
Birdeye For Business

This profile is powered by Birdeye. Over 100,000 businesses use Birdeye everyday to get more reviews and manage all customer feedback. Birdeye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Learn more about Birdeye

55 reviews
51 reviews have no rating
Sort By:
titilola S. review for New York Prime
titilola S. on Insider Pages

13 years ago

02/13/2010, 01:07 AM
Best steak in town! This is the spot for fine dining with the best steak in town! A bit pricey but worth the money. Great service guaranteed.
eileen unger review for New York Prime
eileen unger on Foursquare

13 years ago

01/07/2010, 01:10 AM
Order anything on the menu - it's worth it. And the extensive wine list makes it that much better. Keep an eye open for special events like cigar and scotch dinners, wine dinners, etc.
BWaldner review for New York Prime
BWaldner on Citysearch

13 years ago

12/15/2009, 00:56 AM
Special occassion....not anymore – I was first introduced to New York Prime by an associate while at a business dinner. I entertain a lot and the meaning of "customer service" means everything to me. I was absolutely amazed with the people, food and atmosphere at NYP! The timing of the staff is PERFECT and the conversation never drifts towards, "where's that waiter"? The food is absolutely fantastic!! I have eaten steak and all types of food all over the country and I can say without a doubt this is the BEST of every world. To top off the evening I asked for a tour on my very first visit and much to my surprise they gave it to me. I now visit this establishment whenever I can with clients or for just a simple evening with my wife. They staff learns you name and the owner is one of kind. Never will you have a guy that owns the joint at a 5 star establishment take your jacket! Trust me when I say if you haven't eaten here then you haven't had a great meal yet.
Featured content

What you need to know about Google customer reviews

What you need to know about Google customer reviews

Creating Loyal Customers from Service Failures

Creating Loyal Customers from Service Failures
Carley Pierce review for New York Prime
Carley Pierce on Foursquare

13 years ago

12/15/2009, 00:49 AM
If you are using Mapquest or your GPS to find NYP Atlanta, be careful. The restaurant has a Peachtree At. address but the entrance is actually off of Lenox Road right across from the AMC at Phipps Pl
mmaurice review for New York Prime
mmaurice on Citysearch

14 years ago

03/23/2009, 01:40 AM
Steady Qulity – Have eaten here many times. Always for a special occasion. Service was as expected. They are not always the nicest but are on top of things. Food was as expected. Get the Steak Fries. They are amazingly huge. It was not overly crowded as it has been in the past. Not sure if that is a sign or just the economy.
poblack review for New York Prime
poblack on Citysearch

15 years ago

11/26/2008, 01:20 AM
Read My Honest Review – Don't let these snooty people make you think a restaurant that allows smoking somehow deserves 1 or 2 stars. I am a non smoker and I did not hesitate giving New York Prime 5 stars. Here's why; My wife and I recently dined at New York Prime. I was a little shocked when I first walked in because my initial impression was that this was a high class, formal restaurant (based on the menu prices and the lambhorgini that was valet parked outside). The place was actually load and smokey like a bar. But that was fine with me. My wife best summed it up when she said it was like an 'old gentleman's club' that had a sophisticated Frat type atmosphere. We were greeted at the door by who we believe was one of the owners or managers who immediately took our coats. The place was packed and everyone including the guest were friendly. The food was awesome. I had the bone in ribeye with baked potato and my wife had the garlic chicken. Both very juicy and filled with flavor. We must have had about 3 or 4 different servers and they all were not only knowledgeable about the menu and wines but also had a keen sense of humor and made us laugh. They made sure we were happy with our food. My wife got a wine she didn't like, and the bartender immediately brought her a different type that she loved (she ordered two glasses). I had two rum and cokes and the bartender made them exactly how I like them. This made the evening go way better then anticipated. We had an amazing first time experience at New York Prime and I would highly recommend it to anyone.
jaymaygm review for New York Prime
jaymaygm on Citysearch

16 years ago

05/22/2007, 02:39 AM
Honestly, Just Average For A Buckhead Steakhouse! – I have been by this restaurant, dozens of times since it has been open. Last night, a business associate was staying next door at the Ritz Carlton Buckhead. My friend insisted I join him here for dinner. As to why he did not ask me where to dine in Buckhead for steak, is beyond me. He is from NYC. Buckhead has many excellent steakhouse fine dining destinations. I was hesitant, but gladly went along. The first thing I noticed, was the smell of strong cigar smoke. I'm not a smoker, and well you know the rest. The menu read nicely, but at these prices, it had better be darn good. I opted for one of those 3-4 lobsters, I usually order across the street, at a well-known NYC steakhouse. The presentation was terrible, Why did my server forget the drawn butter? And my friend's steak was overcooked. I just smiled, and thought about all the other really great steakhouses in Buckhead. Our waiters attitude, was that of someone serving a salesman at an auto convention. I dine out several times a week, and I will never come back here, even if my friend is from New York!
deehendricks review for New York Prime
deehendricks on Citysearch

16 years ago

01/05/2007, 01:58 AM
Great Food and Customer Service – I picked out New York Prime for our office dinner. There were 18 of us and we all agreed that it was one of the best meals we had ever eaten. They served us two large trays of appetizers that were delicious. It had oysters, lumb crab, crab claws and shrimp. Then along with our steaks and side dishes we were all stuffed. Everything was cooked to perfection. I will recommend this resturant to everyone. Not only was the food and atmosphere perfect but the custmer service was at the top of the chart. We had two waiters the entire time and we never wanted for anything. Charles was one of them and I sorry but the young ladies name I can't remember something like Kalen. We will be back. A great time had by all.
jsmythe01 review for New York Prime
jsmythe01 on Citysearch

16 years ago

01/03/2007, 01:21 AM
Awful atmosphere! VERY VERY VERY smoky!!! – DO NOT GO TO THIS PLACE unless you are a smoker or don't mind the smoke. This place was awful!!! My friends got sick and threw up because of the poor ventilation due to the cigar and cigarette smoke! The bar was right next to the dining area and you can see how smoky the place was, it was suffocating! It didn't matter where you sat, the smoke was overwhelming! NY Prime made a huge mistake by allowing smoking because it brought the classiness of this overpriced place way way down! The appetizers were excellent, but the lobster (3 pound minimum) was over priced! $70 for a lobster that the waiter had to clean for us on the cart because it wouldn't fit on the table with other dishes. The restrooms were nice, however, you'd have to make your way through the thick smoke just to get there! The wait staff was excellent. The food wasn't anything to brag about.
Footer Banner 2021
Get more reviews. Get more customers.

Get more reviews from your customers with Birdeye. Dominate search results. Beat local competitors. Grow your business. Easy, done.