Cottage Hill Diamonds's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Cottage Hill Diamonds

5.0

About this business

Cottage Hill Diamonds is Chicagoland's engagement and fine jewelry destination. Local, family-owned and operated, we treat each customer like family. 

Location details

125 N York St, Elmhurst, IL, 60126, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
MonClosed
Tue12:00 p.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Wed12:00 p.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Thu12:00 p.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Fri12:00 p.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Sat10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
SunClosed
5.0797 reviews
Select a rating
Amanda R.'s profile image
Amanda R. 
10 years ago

I Love Cottage Hill Diamonds. Over a year ago I went in looking for a gift for my one-year old goddaughter. I wanted something that I could add to each year and make special for her and I. I ended up choosing a charm bracelet (non-Pandora). The help to make sure the gift was perfect, was outstanding. This year, the charm I wanted was sold-out and my goddaughter lives in another state. Cottage Hill had the charm ordered and delivered right to her. I did not have to do a thing! I usually work with Collin (he has sized and appr... read more

Heather S.'s profile image
Heather S. 
10 years ago

I just picked up a ring that Andrew helped me re-design. I can not express how happy I am. The customer service was awesome and my ring turned out beautiful! Thanks again, Cottage Hill Diamonds and Andrew for everything!! 

Ashley T.'s profile image
Ashley T. 
12 years ago

Cottage Hill Diamonds is amazing. My boyfriend Matt and I had been searching for a place to purchase my engagement ring from and we had went from Jewelers Row to all the typical jewelry stores such as Kay and Jared, but were sadly disappointed. No one seemed to treat us seriously and when they did they showed us rings thousands of dollars above our price range. For awhile we felt like giving up then we decided to go to Cottage Hill which is in my home town. After visiting the store and speaking with Joe we knew immediately t... read more

Christopher S.'s profile image
Christopher S. 
12 years ago

Cottage Hill Diamonds was incredible!! They were very eager to match the style of ring that I wanted; so much so, that they were able to custom make a ring for me within 3-weeks! For those unaware of the average time it takes just to ship a ring to the seller, it's anywhere from 4-6 weeks. Collin Hill in particular provided me a great deal of feedback on the status of my ring and checked in with me every couple of days to let me know how things were going. So not only was the ring incredibly beautiful, but I also received in... read more

joey d.'s profile image
12 years ago

My experience at Cottage Hill was amazing. The staff was so friendly and professional. They made the experience of designing an engagement ring unforgettable. I was so nervous to begin with, and at Cottage Hill I felt like I was at home and put at ease. I couldn't imagine going through this experience anywhere else. They have my business for life and I can't recommend them enough! Much love to my guys, gals and Jack at Cottage Hill! 

Rachel C.'s profile image
Rachel C. 
12 years ago

My husband and I could not imagine having chosen another jewelry store for my engagement ring. We drive an hour just to come to Cottage Hill. The entire staff is so wonderful. Andrew has always been so helpful. They know us by name and talk to us like we have been friends for years. Any questions I have I am able to email and have them answered. They have customers for life. 

Mary Jeanne W.'s profile image
Mary Jeanne W. 
12 years ago

I had a wonderful experience shopping at Cottage Hill Diamonds. Actually, I was in to have several pieces of jewelry repaired/cleaned. Within minutes of entering the beautiful showroom, I was greeted with offers of bottled water and chocolates...not a bad way to start! Joe and the entire staff were helpful and knowledgeable and my jewelry came back looking absolutely beautiful. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this established Elmhurst business. They have been around for a long time with good reason. 

J C.'s profile image
12 years ago

Excellent Service – We had a great experience buying an engagement ring at Cottage Hill. Andrew and the entire staff were patient and accomodating, spending a lot of time with us over multiple visits to help us find the perfect ring. They went the extra mile to specially order items for us to view, and there was never any pressure to buy now or exceed our budget. We love the ring and highly recommend Cottage Hill for the great personal service. 

mchammer87's profile image
mchammer87 
13 years ago

Best Jewelry Store in the suburbs – If you appreciate fine customer service and attention to detail, Cottage Hill Diamonds is the place to go. The owners are very friendly and involved and the staff knows their stuff. Everyone is very polite and knowledgable on what they are selling. My fiance and I bought our engagement rings here and they worked with us to customize them to exactly what we wanted. Not to mention they have some funny ads and everyone there has a good sense of humor. We have been there for their "ladies nigh... read more

Frequently asked questions about Cottage Hill Diamonds

How is Cottage Hill Diamonds rated?

Cottage Hill Diamonds has a 5 star rating with 797 reviews. 

When is Cottage Hill Diamonds open?

Cottage Hill Diamonds is closed now. It will open at 10:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com