Commodore Resort Hotel's cover image
Claimed

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Commodore Resort Hotel

3.7

About this business

Commodore Resort provides accommodations for leisure travelers. Its rooms and suits feature microwaves, refrigerators, hair dryers, air conditioners, phones and cable televisions. Commodore Resort has a restaurant that offers a variety of dining options. Its nearby attractions include parks, museums and golf courses. The resort is located Downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio. On 272 Delaware Ave 

Location details

272 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH, 43456, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
3.7798 reviews
Select a rating
Gwen Hughes Lindsey's profile image
Gwen Hughes Lindsey 
6 years ago

Our room had cobwebs and moths everywhere and the floors I don’t think had been cleaned in over a week or so . Sheets were dirty I asked for our bed to be changed and room cleaned up and I was told maids were gone for the night . ( mind you it was 3 pm). I guess this is cause we weren’t the normal college crowd age that don’t care . I’m not old either but I’m not sleeping in filth . So let alone say we went back to mainland for a tent and moved up to the camp ground . I will never return. Read all reviews there is plenty mor... read more

Business response:

Sorry your stay was not enjoyable. Many people return to our location and call it there second home and would never go anywhere else. Upon check out you stated that you would put a bad review everywhere you could since you did not get a free stay with us, thanks for your review and I am sure others can read between the lines. For your information and others, the moths you are referring to are mayflies, they cannot be helped. The come from the bottom of the lake and are attracted to light and light clothing. They live for 24 ... read more

Darcy Offinger's profile image
Darcy Offinger 
6 years ago

wanted to stay close to town. thought it would be a nice place to stay. got to our room & our view, was a brick wall. we always ck out the rm before hand, just to make sure everything is ok. my husband noticed a piece of glass sticking out from behind the TV stand. come to find out, from the cleaning lady & manager that the previous renters had broken the pic while there & hid the glass. the floor had to be swept & mopped, bc it was a mess. later that night, we wanted to use the jacuzzi, only to find out, the button was brok... read more

Business response:

As the manager, I apologized for the glass not being found before your stay. We refreshed your room, gave you bar bucks for the broken Jacuzzi. I only work mornings not sure what manger you are referring to that thought you were a bother. Nor did I ever tell someone to be quiet. I did refuse to give you a free stay but that was all. Hopefully your next stay on the island will be more enjoyable. 

Darcy Offinger's profile image
Darcy Offinger 
6 years ago

Business response:

As the manager, I apologized for the glass not being found before your stay. We refreshed your room, gave you bar bucks for the broken Jacuzzi. I only work mornings not sure what manger you are referring to that thought you were a bother. Nor did I ever tell someone to be quiet. I did refuse to give you a free stay but that was all. Hopefully your next stay on the island will be more enjoyable. 

Krysten Brown's profile image
Krysten Brown 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

We love this place! We come every year and stay in a pool view room. It’s the best pool/bar on the island. So close to everything and now that Cameo Pizza is here we are set for the week! The only thing I could recommend is that they clean the floors and the upper deck better on the pool view rooms. Our feet are always black just walking in our room, and we feel it could be better. We will return as always! 

Business response:

Thank you for the great review and glad you here! We would love recommendations on good floor cleaners, we have tried about every brand on the market in the stores, Amazon, etc. and they all seem to make the floor look clean once we are done mopping it twice after each turn. Than after a few hours after people have checked in they are dirty. We believe it due to the outside area which we pressure wash as much as possible but it is tough when there are stay overs. Open to suggestions. 

Kristy Herwat's profile image
Kristy Herwat 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

Great location and great visit!! Always clean and ready early. Would highly recommend staying here!!!! 

Business response:

Thank you for the awesome review! Hope you return soon! 

Cambria Mansfield's profile image
Cambria Mansfield 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

Our whole experience has been great here the past two times we've stayed! 

Business response:

Thank you for the review glad you returned!!! 

Avon Beacham Byrd's profile image
Avon Beacham Byrd 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

We had an amazing time at the Commodore Resort! Room was clean and updated...air was working percectly... The view of the pool was great and the pool party was a blast!!! We will be back!!!! 

Business response:

Thank you for the great review! We look forward to your return to our location! 

Sheila Marshall-Warnick's profile image
Sheila Marshall-Warnick 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

was able to check in hours earlier than expected..friendly and clean..wasn't too happy that the pool area and pool bar closed early around 7:00 pm 

Business response:

Sorry the mayflies were coming our way with the winds and we felt it was to close down than have the bugs interfere with your fun!. 

Steve Mcleod's profile image
Steve Mcleod 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

Me and my wife have been here several times. ALWAYS a great time for a weekend get-away. Rent a golf cart and just have a seriously good time with good food, reasonable shopping and great people. Looking for some friends to go with this year! Saw the Killer Flamingos for the first time here 😃 

Business response:

Thank you for the great review! We are glad you always have a great time!! Have you kayaked while you are here yet? We have maps at the front desk with the kayak launch sites. 

Frequently asked questions about Commodore Resort Hotel

How is Commodore Resort Hotel rated?

Commodore Resort Hotel has a 3.7 star rating with 798 reviews. 

When is Commodore Resort Hotel open?

Commodore Resort Hotel is closed now. It will open on Monday at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com

Popular in Put-In-Bay, OH