Commodore Resort Hotel's cover image
Claimed

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Commodore Resort Hotel

3.7

About this business

Commodore Resort provides accommodations for leisure travelers. Its rooms and suits feature microwaves, refrigerators, hair dryers, air conditioners, phones and cable televisions. Commodore Resort has a restaurant that offers a variety of dining options. Its nearby attractions include parks, museums and golf courses. The resort is located Downtown Put-in-Bay, Ohio. On 272 Delaware Ave 

Location details

272 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH, 43456, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
3.7798 reviews
Select a rating
Cassie Bronge's profile image
Cassie Bronge 
5 years ago

I will never stay at the Commodore again. We had an awful experience and the hotel is incredibly overpriced for what we got. The rooms were dirty and we didn’t receive room service for the entire time we were there. There was mold in the shower, garbage in the hallways, and trash in the stairwell that stayed there the entire weekend. The showers gave off a high pitch squeal when you did use them and the rooms didn’t have the hair dryers that we were told they did. Our room door was busted so it didn’t close all the way witho... read more

Business response:

Hi Cassie, Thank you for your comments. I myself picked up the trash and yes again the next day there was more. It is a times hard to keep up with throughout the night, but it is taken care of in the morning and again in the afternoon. As for problems with your room, had you came to us we would have happily corrected the items missed. Please try us again when it is slower like during the week. 

Cassie Bronge's profile image
Cassie Bronge 
5 years ago

Business response:

Hi Cassie, Thank you for your comments. I myself picked up the trash and yes again the next day there was more. It is a times hard to keep up with throughout the night, but it is taken care of in the morning and again in the afternoon. As for problems with your room, had you came to us we would have happily corrected the items missed. Please try us again when it is slower like during the week. 

Carrie Baumgardner's profile image
Carrie Baumgardner 
recommend  Recommended
5 years ago

Excellent customer service! They are willing to go the extra mile! 

Business response:

Thank you for taking the time to review our location! Hope to see you again. 

Terra Agosta's profile image
Terra Agosta 
5 years ago

My husband and I went for our anniversary weekend. It felt like I was living in a college dorm again. The pool bar was loud and the staff was rude. Every night we had a 3 am wake up from the drunks coming back. The walls were thin we could hear everything going on outside and in the neighboring rooms. We decided to leave a day early and were rudely informed that we wouldn’t get a refund. I didn’t even ask for one I just wanted to leave. I won’t stay here again. 

Business response:

Hi Terra, I am sorry your anniversary was not everything you expected it to be. Had we been aware of the noise we could have asked the other guests to quiet down or moved you to another location. I usually put a card and/ or flowers if I am notified about an anniversary. I apologize if the staff was rude, however, we do not do refunds on weekends as these are minimum night stays and check out time is 11 am. You departed in the middle of the afternoon and there was no staff to turn the room over for renting. Had it been earli... read more

Lynn Silverwood's profile image
Lynn Silverwood 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

clean rooms friendly staff 

Maggie Jones's profile image
Maggie Jones 
6 years ago

the view was beautiful of the pool, and the price was very fair, but i called to ask about the pool bar and they said it ran until labor day, we were there the 3rd week in august and not only was it not running but the pool was absolutely frigid!! nobody stayed in it for more than 10 minutes at a time. I would not recommended/ stay there again unless the pool gets heated as it gets chilly by the lake even in august, otherwise you may as well stay at a hotel or b&b. The staff was helpful and lovation is convinient but over al... read more

Business response:

I am sorry you could not enjoy the pool or pool bar, a lot of depends on weather and business. Unfortunately it is out of the hotels control as it is a separate business. 

Terri Williams's profile image
Terri Williams 
recommend  Recommended
6 years ago

My friend and I stayed here to celebrate her upcoming birthday and this was the best place ever! Customer Service was very attentative and helpful with all requests , locals informed us the ferry would shut down late saturday so if we wanted not to be stuck on the island until mon or tues we had better catch the first jet express back, we did and was refunded the sat nite we had prepaid, I Thank You so very much! our room was very comfortable and clean and very close to all the action downtown. Will definatly stay again when... read more

Business response:

Thank you for taking the time to write a review about our location! Hope to see you again when the weather is better so you enjoy the entire stay! 

Miranda Jade Eberle's profile image
Miranda Jade Eberle 
6 years ago

***BED BUGS**PICTURES INCLUDED*** This is the absolutely worst hotel that I have ever stayed in. The last day that we were there we found bed bugs in our room, we took it up with the manager and she claims that “we have never had this problem.” I decided to do some reading on reviews and come to find out that they have. She informed me that the only thing they can do is give us a 20% refund and that wasn’t good enough for me. My thought was bringing them home, I’ve never had bed bugs nor do I ever wish to have them. She told... read more

Business response:

To set the record straight: I never got messages that you called. Today I spoke to your father, not you. I never said you brought them I said you must have taken them all with you as we fond no traces and have had numerous guests stay there since without complaints. Also these are not our sheets. 

Miranda Jade Eberle's profile image
Miranda Jade Eberle 
6 years ago

Business response:

To set the record straight: I never got messages that you called. Today I spoke to your father, not you. I never said you brought them I said you must have taken them all with you as we fond no traces and have had numerous guests stay there since without complaints. Also these are not our sheets. 

Frequently asked questions about Commodore Resort Hotel

How is Commodore Resort Hotel rated?

Commodore Resort Hotel has a 3.7 star rating with 798 reviews. 

When is Commodore Resort Hotel open?

Commodore Resort Hotel is closed now. It will open on Monday at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com

Popular in Put-In-Bay, OH