Ye Olde Tollgate Steakhouse

hoyas2000 

on Citysearch

20 years ago

O.k. but not worth the price – I guess the options are small in the steakhouse realm in Westchester, but this wasn't great. Granted it was a couple years ago, but from the other review it sounds like it is the same. We had an o.k. dinner, but to charge those prices it needs to be great. The portions on the side dishes were good. The acoustics in the restaurant weren't great either. There was a loud party in the same room and it was deafening. I would save your money and go into NYC for a good steak dinner! Service was o.k. 

iamfreenow31 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

yuk – we went on valentines day and i have ti say if it wasnt v-day i wouldve said something- the meat was verrrrrrry fatty overpriced and they sat us in this horrible spot- we asked to move and eventually did but it was the worst steak i ever had- the surf and turf was wayyyyy overpriced for what you actually get- also the steak was burnt! (not the way i ordered- i would never recommend this to anyone! stay away! 

lancemanhattan 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Great Steaks – This restaurant is a great place for your steak. We had a private room upstairs for 16 people ad it was great. Succulent shrimp for appetizers, a huge 4 person porterhouse, creamed spinach, sauteed mushrooms and hash browns. It all hit the spot and at a decent price too. Parking can be a pain but it well worth it. 

dfaccas 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Good Steak in Westchester. – A Peter Luger imitation, which slightly lacks Luger's quality. I'd rather go to Flames when I'm in Westchester: the steak, apps and décor are much better (Flames is even better than Luger's).