Rothmann's Steakhouse

kal102374 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

This place has good steak. If you tried all the other steak houses in the city and want to add another one to the list of top steakhouses, I recommend it. However service was a bit disappointing. It didn't run evenly with ambience and food quality. I would first make sure you've been to Ruth Chris, Lugers, Angelo & Maxies, Bobby vans, S & W, the Palm & Mortons first. I think Rothmans rates along the lines of Old Homestead, Nick & Stefs, & the Post house. I still need to try Sparks & Dylan Prime. 

ssgiblin 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Yummy in my Tummy – I love this place....you are all crazy. The steak rocks and the sides are great. All cuts, creamed spinach, potato croquettes and wine galore! Sides are important to me when eating a steak! 

Em91871 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Overpriced For Whatcha Get – Food was tasty, but nothing extraordinary...When the check came, they almost needed to give me oxygen- $300 for 4 and that was just basic dinner and a drink apiece. I had the crabcakes- decent, but on the dry side and a little burned. 2 of my dinner companions had steak which they reported to be very good and my other friend had sea bass, which she said was extremely salty. Overall, staff was very friendly and we did have a nice time. 

elizabethweaver01 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Great people and food – Ate here the first night in New York. The service was absolutely wonderful. They were very, very attentive and very patient when we were not sure what we wanted. All my daughter had to do was comment on a certain bread they served and the waiter produced more for her to take with her. My husband's steak was very tender and my soup and Rothmann's salad was very tasty. 

gsnyc 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

Attractive but not a real steakhouse – Steaks were acceptable but not great, aervice was acceptable but not great, drinks were good. I would call it a steakhouse for visiting businessmen and their wives.