Randy's Pizza

Claire S. 

on Citysearch

13 years ago

so legit. – The food was so delicious. I got the lasagna, and the portion was huge. It also came with a salad and rolls, which were great. I only paid around $14 for all of it plus delivery, and it came quickly. I wish I knew about this place sooner. 

nospam77 

on Citysearch

13 years ago

Very good but delivery is a risk – 4 stars because of delivery issues. Randy’s Pizza on Martin Luther makes excellent pizza. But I’ve had not so great experiences with delivery. One time when I opened the box the whole pizza was at one end. The box had obviously been turned on its side. On some occasions I got a great pizza in a fairly reasonable time. Once something happened so my order was very late and cold. I love their pizza but quit ordering takeout. Though the staff’s personality is a bit peculiar I highly recommend v... read more

jennypenny622 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

great place – i am very very picky when it comes to pizza and when my we moved here i needed to find a good place and this place is great. not only was the pizza good but so are the subs. when you tell them how you want something they do it right the first time. also going in for the second time and was completely blown away by how friendly and nice the family is, we must have sat and talked about ny since that is where i am from and so was the one gentleman. all around great service and atmosphere and food. 

1031DH 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

Pizza Not Cooked Completely – This was my first time trying Randy's Pizza, I called in an order for 18" Meat Lovers pizza. After picking up the pizza and sitting down for dinner I was disappointed to find that the dough was soft/sponge-like around the outside of the pie. The toppings consisted of pepperoni, bacon bits, and small bits of what I presumed to be hamburger or sausage. The pizza itself was so tuff that I could barely cut it with a knife, let alone chew it. 

pizzaguy2011 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

Good stuff – Great place for lunch. They need teach their other location a thing or two. 

CombatZAK 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

Do NOT trust them with call-in orders... – It's unfortunate, really. Randy's used to be one of my favorite pizza places. The staff is friendly enough, but apparently they're dishonest too. On two separate occasions now, I've called in a pickup order and after receiving a wait-time, I've shown up to find that they hadn't even started on my order and actually expected me to wait around while they made my food. The first time this happened they waited till I paid to tell me. I was lucky enough to be ablet o pull my credit card ... read more

ATester 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

good taste, but questionable – Generally taste food. Not at all health conscious and lately I was horrified to find a piece of mud in my salad. They exchanged if for a new salad, but my lunch time was ruined and they didn't offer to take it off the bill or a coupon. 

cbowen 

on Citysearch

16 years ago

Best pizza in town – By far the best pizza around. I grew up in Philadelphia, and this place makes pizza like I grew up with. They use real mozzarella, not the fake stuff the chain places use. Good pizza can be warmed and sold by the slice, and Randy fits the bill for that. And, the slices are huge! If you want a slice or two, go to Randy's. If you want a whole pie, go to Randy's. Their cheese steaks are very close to what I grew up with in PA. By far the best pizza that I've had while living in the South. 

Netfa 

on Citysearch

16 years ago

Excellent Pizza!!!!! – These are the biggest slices in town, with the best taste. The cheese and sauce have excellent flavor. This is the only place I buy pizza, I love it. I'm spoiled by Brooklyn's Italians.