Westville

geefunk3 

on Citysearch

20 years ago

Awesome – I read the positive reviews on Citysearch and decided to give it a try, and I've been eating Westville practically once a week every since! Every thing I've tried has always been delicious -- if you're into simple, but tasty good food, this is it! It's not fancy, it's not pretentious, and thank God for that. Otherwise they probably wouldn't deliver and I'd be in big trouble. :-) 

timmie32 

on Citysearch

20 years ago

Perfection – I ate here for the first time and have to say it's the best burger and fries I've had in NYC. No frills, simple decor, and no pretension. I don't know about other reviews, but the service and food were awesome. 

juliet_of_the_spirits 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

Slow as hell – Food is great, but the service was inexplicably slow. Extrememly loud, annoying clientele who shout at each other and on their cell phones as if drunk. But killer tuna sandwich and burger are incomparable. 

yourdabest 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

Hidden Burger Joint – First off ... this place is a whole in the wall. It is tiny and you will sit right on top of each other. So if its comfort your looking for this is not the place; however, if you want good food at a reasonable price, then this is the place. What impressed me the most was their burger. It KILLS Corner Bistro, The Burger Joint, McHales...etc. By far the best burger I've had in NYC. Its worth checking out! 

spiggz 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

great food – I had great pork chops with sauteed mushrooms and my friend had a lemon pepper chicken salad sandwich. We had mac and cheese as appetizers and everything was delicious. While the entrees were pricey for homey food it's well worth it! The butterscotch pudding tasted like pure butterscotch. The service was flaky and slow. Also the whole dining area feels like a hallway in size and shape though it is open on one end. 

Allison Austin 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

Classic American food served in a charming cafe that's bustling with locals looking for simple, inexpensive eats. – West Villagers embrace this big-city version of a small-town cafe for casual meals eaten in-house or taken out. Though you might find yourself cursing the placement of the bathroom behind the kitchen, the friendly staff and a comprehensive menu of reasonably priced fare more than make up for the challenge of dodging cooks on the way to the john. Simple salads, burgers and hot dogs are solid choices for lunch or... read more

99jhp 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

Fall of the House of Westville – While starting off as fans of this miniature comfort food establishment, the lackadaisical service and varying food quality has soured our tastes. I was not going to bother commenting, but the masses of people now lining up to fit into this elf-size establishment for Sunday brunch remind me of the also over-hyped Magnolia Bakery just around the corner and the deluge of ignorant pedestrians armed with the latest guidebook. The kicker to publish a review was when we ordered takeout one evening ... read more

philochs76 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

You Must Eat Here! – Westville has quickly become a staple in my NY must-eat restaurant list. I've gone several times and never had a bad meal, and it's WAY easier on the wallet than anywhere else of comparable quality. I live on the upper west side, so I don't just think of this as a neighborhood place! Get the butterscotch pudding, even if you don't think you like that sort of thing. The pies and cobblers are homemade and perfectly done, the mac and cheese is amazing, even the steak sandwich is perfectly cooked and tender.... read more

bargain_girl 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

Disappointing – Had a horrible fish fry there -- the fish, although fried, was soggy, and the fries were not very tasty. Plus, the prices were all above $10 for entrees -- which is not a bargain in my opinion -- and apparently the cobbler the Citysearch reviewer mentioned is seasonal, because it wasn't there when I went.