Waterstone Mortgage Corporation's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Waterstone Mortgage Corporation

2.5

About this business

Waterstone Mortgage Corporation offers mortgage lending and home, retail, and construction loan services. 

Location details

N25w23255 Paul Rd, Pewaukee, WI, 53072, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
2.520 reviews
Select a rating
Jim C's profile image
Jim C 
2 weeks ago

Got my loan in Oct of 2024. Loan was just sold off to another company. All my mortgage payments were paid each month. This is a very shaddy company. Do not go to them for a mortgage. Period. Now I got to go threw the entire process of creating a new account, setting up auto pay once again. Oh and they are very rude pertaining to 1 certain person. DO NOT USE THEM AT ALL. 

Business response:

Good Afternoon. We apologize, however, based on the information submitted in this review, we are unable to identify you as a Waterstone Mortgage customer. Please reach out to our Corporate Customer Relations Manager at ************ to provide more details. Thank you. 

Ruth M's profile image
Ruth M 
6 months ago

Duration of loan: June 2024-September 20224 My loan was given to Waterstone Mortgage from the local bank manager. This is when everything went downhill for me. My lender/holder of my loan was changed from USDA-R, Equity loan, FHA, Forward Loan company all within 3 months. My closing was delayed 4 times for the same reason which didn't make any sense. I was told by the loan officer that the underwriter decided that they didn't want to recognize the income from a rental property that has been rented for over 18 years. The inco... read more

Business response:

Ms. ********* at Waterstone Mortgage, we take all customer feedback very seriously. Through every transaction, we strive to provide the highest level of communication and the utmost transparency. After a thorough investigation, we've determined that the Loan Originator you worked with went above and beyond to provide you the same communication and transparency that every one of our customers deserve. After receiving your full application and disclosures in August, we worked diligently with our underwriting department and mul... read more

Patricia H's profile image
Patricia H 
6 months ago

Amy is helping my son with his first time home loan and so far the process has been really easy and informative. I am looking forward to making this dream possible for him and I appreciate Amy so much for the guidance and support. Thank you!***** 

Eric C's profile image
Eric C 
10 months ago

Painful process and I underwriters seem to be very confused I had to get multiple cashiers checks and was given the run around through the entire process with the underwriters. Chaotic and disorganized process would not recommend. 

Business response:

****, we are sorry that you feel the process was disorganized and chaotic. We do strive to provide every customer with the most timely, clear, and concise information throughout the transaction. Some transactions can be more challenging than others, especially dealing with multiple agency guidelines and overlays. Our underwriters do their very best to streamline the process for our customers, while focusing on 100% compliance. We appreciate your feedback, and we were very honored to have helped you with your financing. 

Heather D's profile image
Heather D 
11 months ago

It took over 4 months to close on a straightforward construction loan due to wild incompetence of staff. This delayed construction significantly and then Waterstone layered on considerable financial penalties when we were not done with construction a mere 6 months later. Deceptive rate-lock setup not in favor of borrower/buyer and used in a sneaky way to lock borrower into rigid penalties well under the allotted 12-month construction term. We feel extremely taken advantage of. Even our attorneys contract review prior to sign... read more

Business response:

Waterstone Mortgage is pleased to have been able to speak with this consumer at great length to help clarify and analyze the details of the transaction, perception vs cause of delays and the accurately disclosed fees associated with a rate lock extension. 

Mark K's profile image
Mark K 
a year ago

Mike ***** is 100% the BEST decision I have made. His team helped me through the whole process with my USDA Rural Loan. I was closed and in my new house in less than 2 months. AND.. Mike and his team, after two years, are still supporting me, and still answer questions and give great advise. Bottom line, these people know their jobs, very professional and honest. If I had to do it Again, Id make the same choice.************ ******* *** ***** 

Business response:

Thank you so much for the 5* review, ****! We're so glad to hear your experience with ******************* and his team was fantastic! We will always be here to support you! 

Lynne C's profile image
Lynne C 
a year ago

Fantastic mortgage company and people working there, but beware - they will sell your mortgage before you can even make a payment. They sold mine to a company called ***************** the most incompetent mortgage investor I've ever dealt with. Check out their ratings here on Yelp. Almost all 1 star. Their customer ********************** has disrespected me and won't help me. I've been trying to get my Veteran's tax exemption for months. They keep taking tax funds out of our mortgage that I don't even owe, and I keep emailin... read more

Business response:

Hello Lynne. We are sorry for the challenges you’ve experienced with the new servicer. We remain committed to providing you top notch service and communication, and we’d be happy to help you navigate through whatever issues you may still be having. Please feel free to call our Customer Relations Manager at 262-701-5925. Thank you. 

Diana B's profile image
Diana B 
a year ago

Joey was extremely helpful and very easy to work with. He called every week, made sure everything was understood, sent emails. Easy to connect with and very knowledgeable. He has a great team. I am so blessed to be in my new home and it was an easy process thanks to Joey and his team. 

Business response:

Thank you for your 5* review, *****! We are so glad you had a wonderful experience with **** and his team! Enjoy your new home! 

Tod A's profile image
Tod A 
a year ago

For me, this company was about the only shining star in a very difficult transaction. Issues with seller, both agents, and numerous mistakes. Michael who I dealt with was very helpful and patient. Yes, the company is out to make money. I still don't understand some of the policies that govern the mortgage business today. However, in the end, good service from Waterstone. 

Business response:

Thank you for the 5 Star Review, ***! We're so happy to hear everything went well with your purchase, with the help of ******* and his team. We hope to work with you again in the future! 

Frequently asked questions about Waterstone Mortgage Corporation

How is Waterstone Mortgage Corporation rated?

Waterstone Mortgage Corporation has a 2.5 star rating with 20 reviews. 

When is Waterstone Mortgage Corporation open?

Waterstone Mortgage Corporation is closed now. It will open tomorrow at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com