Donatos's cover image

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Donatos

3.3

About this business

Location details

8880 E 96th St, Fishers, IN, 46037, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
3.3275 reviews
Select a rating
Crystal Bee's profile image
Crystal Bee 
7 years ago

I ordered a little over a week ago and after 2.5 hours of waiting for my order to arrive by delivery, called to cancel the order. The crazy part is that they’d sent me an email after an hour to tell me that my order was in route. I also submitted a complaint and the manager gave me a $25 credit. I decided to give them another chance and called today to place an order for a spinach pizza. The order arrived and I open the box to find a chicken tomato and spinach pizza. That is not what I ordered. I called to have the delivery ... read more

Lauren Etta's profile image
Lauren Etta 
7 years ago

We have been waiting on a pizza we ordered since 6:15pm. i have called 3 times now. it is now after 9pm and no pizza. i just called 30 min ago the guy said it had left and would be here in 10 min. it is now over 30 min later. I did talk to the manager who seemed really nice and did offer a discount for next order. But this is crazy. 3 hours for a pizza? The driver is still not here. We already paid. our family is hungry, tired and sleepy. This is awful. 

Business response:

We are so sorry about this. We will address this immediately. Please send your name, contact info and the store you had an issue with acoons@donatos.com so we can make it right. 

Jessica Pace's profile image
Jessica Pace 
7 years ago

This is the second time I’ve ordered pick up and they had not even been put in the oven when I went to pick up at my scheduled time!! 😡 Hungry kids with no food is no fun! 

Business response:

We hate that you had a bad experience. Please send your name, contact info and the store you had an issue with to acoons@donatos.com so we can make it right. 

David E. Weaver's profile image
David E. Weaver 
8 years ago

Order arrived incorrectly and not the least bit hot; lukewarm at best. I waited nearly an hour for that privilege. When trying to call the location, no one answered. I actually had to call another Donatos location so they could try to relay my message. When I finally got ahold of someone, I was informed I would need to wait another hour for a re-delivery. I'm glad I don't need CPR from them tonight! 

Rhonda Reed Sacks's profile image
Rhonda Reed Sacks 
8 years ago

Okay so I ordered delivery I waited over two hours. I called many times and finally someone answered the phone. I asked when my food would arrive. The gentleman stated that they put the address in wrong and tried calling twice. Well I stated I never received a call and asked if it would be delivered. He started they were now closed and that wasn't going to happen. Completely rude and not the way to run a business. 

Rose Bernard Evans's profile image
Rose Bernard Evans 
8 years ago

Wonderful pizza, wonderful service. Wish we didn’t have to drive so far to go to Donato’s Pizza, but they closed both Anderson and Muncie locations. 

Business response:

Thanks for your awesome review! 

Clayton Culver's profile image
Clayton Culver 
8 years ago

We came in to town for a soccer tournament and about 20 of us went to donatos the service was terrible and we even had to go up to the cashier to order then had to get our own refills and clear the tables. Personally I had the boneless chicken wings with mild sauce and they were disgusting. 

Christopher C Cary's profile image
Christopher C Cary 
9 years ago

Donato's Pizza on 96th and Lantern has the worst service. 

Business response:

SO sorry Christopher! PLEASE resport this to Donatos.com/customer-service so that a manager can follow up with you! 

Alice Sheehan's profile image
Alice Sheehan 
9 years ago

We went mid afternoon today, our server was named Cassidy(?) I think. She was very helpful (first time there from out of town) and attentive. We had the meats pizza, it was amazing. Brought back an Italian side salad and hot wings for our supper, and they rocked also!! Thank you Donatos and Cassidy for a great experience!! 

Business response:

Thanks for your awesome review. We hope to see you again soon! Text "PIZZA" to 88188 to get over $500 in savings throughout the year! 

Frequently asked questions about Donatos

How is Donatos rated?

Donatos has a 3.3 star rating with 275 reviews. 

When is Donatos open?

Donatos is closed now. It will open tomorrow at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com