Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria

3.9

About this business

28" Original Big Boy Pizza 

Location details

1260 NW Maynard Rd, Cary, NC, 27513, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
3.9107 reviews
Select a rating
Coley529's profile image
Coley529 
16 years ago

Great service and great food!! – All the food here is so great!!! We eat here about 2 times a week, between the NY style pizza and the Gnocchi's we can never decide what to get. I am from NY and this pizza is the closest I can find here in NC. The family that owns it is always so friendly and nice when we go in!! They have even upgraded a bit and started waiting tables and making it more of a restaurant and not just a pizza joint!!! 

orion619's profile image
orion619 
16 years ago

Found A Real Pizza Parlor – Honestly, I wasn't looking for this place but stumbled onto it after sampling a "real" NY bagel store. What was dissapointing about my bagel store was more than made up for with my pizza discovery. The crust was perfect and the sauce was very tasty. Also sampled their marinated mozzerella which was extremely flavorfull. I'm from Brooklyn living here about 3 months now and now I at least have a favorite pizza parlor. 

anthony357's profile image
anthony357 
17 years ago

Felt like we were home in New York............ – We heard about Brooklyn Boys but never got around to eating there until today. We live about an hour away and happened to be in the neighborhood of Brooklyn Boys (gps told us that), so we decided to try it out and besides we were just dying for some real NY tasting pizza. To our delight, it was worth every bite and the young man and his wife that were working there today were just as excited as we were to know we were in heaven with our first bite. Being from Long Island, NY a... read more

ucfhf's profile image
17 years ago

Love the pizza – We drive to get Brooklyn Boy's Pizza. The pizza is always good, even with the special toppings we get. I used to work around the corner from here, so we went for lunch. The booths are old-style, which contributes to the feel of the place. The folks who work there have always been nice. Honestly, the only issue I've ever had is the bathroom being a bit messy during the lunch rush. 

mebbie76's profile image
mebbie76 
17 years ago

Unpredicatable Pizza – When we first ate here in May 2007, the pizza was excellent! It honestly was the best pizza I ever had in NC (I'm from NY). However, the past 3 times I've ordered pizza, I've gotten the wrong toppings and/or a rock hard crust. Once I even tried to order pizza 2.5 hours before they were suppose to close and they had stopped answering the phones. When I stopped in (I live right around the corner), they told me that they ran out of pizza dough. How does a pizza place run out of pizza dough 2.5 hours befor... read more

nyitalgal43's profile image
nyitalgal43 
17 years ago

its all about the pizzzzzzzzzzzza! – BROOKLYN BOYS PIZZA IS THE BEST IN NC THAT I HAVE HAD.THE SERVICE IS THE BEST THERE,FRENDLY,GREAT WITH PEOPLE,AND THE YOUNG MEN THAT WORK ON THE WEEKEND ARE ALSO VERY VERY GOOD AND CAN MAKE A GREAT PIZZA PIE. THE BIG BOYS PIZZA IS THE BEST 28" IN TOWN. I WOULD GO BACK TO BROOKLYN BOYS PIZZA ANYTIME............I GIVE THE SERVICE A 10 AND THE FOOD A 10 AND THE PIZZA IS OUT OF THIS WORLD ::::>>>>>> 

thughes113's profile image
thughes113 
19 years ago

WOW...what a deal! The Big Boy Pizza is delicious and perfect for a family of four...you even have leftovers! The pizza is NY style and we love it. They will cut it anyway you want and in squares is perfect, easy and not messy. Just one word of caution...The Big Boy pizza....for a family of four...don't buy two....just TOO much pizza!!! :-) 

mmouse959's profile image
mmouse959 
20 years ago

THE Best Pizza – The best Pizza in Cary. Quick, cheap, delicious. Good specials. By the slice available. Sausage is excellent. Suggest for a quick lunch or carry out. 

thefishers's profile image
thefishers 
22 years ago

MAMA MIA!!!!!! – BROOKLYN BOYS has the best pizza in the Triangle. Period. No other pizza is as authentic. The food isn't watered down like the other restaurants chains in the Triangle. The service is excellent and the staff is fantastic and personable; that alone will make you want to come back. The prices can't be beat either. BROOKLYN BOYS, if you ever read this, remember the couple from Raleigh :-) 

Frequently asked questions about Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria

How is Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria rated?

Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria has a 3.9 star rating with 107 reviews. 

When is Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria open?

Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria is closed now. It will open at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com