The Toy Barn's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

The Toy Barn

4.0

About this business

The Toy Barn Team is relentlessly committed to offering the best selection of Magnificent Previously Owned Automobiles, while providing each customer with an exceptional experience. 

Location details

5100 Post Rd, Columbus, OH, 43017, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
4.01,247 reviews
Select a rating
Curt C.'s profile image
Curt C. 
2 years ago

Well, unfortunately this was an online nightmare buying experience. It started off good as they gave me a good price for my trade-in to buy the 2021 BMW X5 they had listed. The pictures they took of the vehicle were good and the car looked to be in good shape. Of course the vehicle was just over a year old (1/21 build). My concern was it had 31K miles on it in a year and had only one BMW service done. I tried to just accept that the first owner had oil changes completed at an independent location. They asked me if I wanted... read more

Bob R.'s profile image
Bob R. 
3 years ago

I had a horrible experience buying a Ferrari from the Toy Barn. Bought a Ferrari from Salesman Greg McDevitt over the phone / internet and there was no reponse to questions and issues that arose. I asked for a paint meter reading 3 different times, which I never received. There was a disolored window switch that was supposed to be replaced before it was shipped to me - never happened. I had to call 5 or 6 times to get him to ship it to me. When it arrived, it was filthly and even had the stock # still in grease pencil o... read more

Jackie R.'s profile image
Jackie R. 
7 years ago

I purchased a BMW Z3 M Roadster from these people at the beginning of June and I still have no title. I have been promised repeatedly that the title would arrive most recently yesterday when they said that they would overnight it. No title. After spending over $20,000 for this car and another $2,800 in repairs to get it inspected I still cannot register and drive this car. Think twice before you buy a vehicle from them 

jake's profile image
8 years ago

I was ready to write a 5-star review on the BMW I purchased 2 days ago. Sale went great - and all done in under 2-hours from test drive to delivery. Wow, love it! But (and there is always a but)... before signing - they read to me what they had done to the car in their "per-inspection"... and it did not include an oil change of all things. So, I worked in the deal to get an oil change included, as I read the comments that is something they often "overlook". But, to my ignorance and my warning to those that follow me her... read more

Jasmine H.'s profile image
Jasmine H. 
10 years ago

Excellent customer service! I will contact them in the future for another Porsche! 

joemaster971's profile image
joemaster971 
11 years ago

Mike was very professional but also very personal during the sales. As of now, my best experience purchasing a car. “My Dream Car”… Bullet is her name. thanks again for a great experience. 

louisroald's profile image
louisroald 
11 years ago

The whole process was easy and stress free. I knew exactly what I wanted and got a great deal. Constantly went out of their way to make sure my needs were met and I was happy. 

Louis R.'s profile image
Louis R. 
11 years ago

The whole process was easy and stress free. I knew exactly what I wanted and got a great deal. Constantly went out of their way to make sure my needs were met and I was happy. 

Deborah W.'s profile image
Deborah W. 
11 years ago

Bought a BMW last week. Very clean, very smooth. My salesman was very knowledgeable about the high-line cars and he got me approved at 3.9% at my bank. Couldn’t be more satisfied. 

Frequently asked questions about The Toy Barn

How is The Toy Barn rated?

The Toy Barn has a 4 star rating with 1,247 reviews. 

When is The Toy Barn open?

The Toy Barn is open now. It will close at 6:00 p.m.  

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com