The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co.

H Scott Kokemueller 

on Google

3 days ago

Bagels are great, BUT the egg sandwich with scrambled eggs needs help. A true NY bagel would have a fried egg; I am from NY. If they switched to Fried eggs they would be perfect 

Jaline campos 

on Google

6 days ago

I found a piece of rope or hair toasted onto my bagel… also the coffee situation is terrible. Why are they making the customers self serve an iced coffee and not even have milk? I paid $40 for 2 bagels and coffee. NOT worth the price. 

Benny P. 

on Google

2 weeks ago

This amateur hour operation runs out of bagels with HOURS left of operating hours constantly. If this is a bagel shop, why run out of bagels by noon? Make more. Do your jobs. Or close shop. Simple as that. Update 2/10/26 - another wasted trip. No bagels Update 2/16/26 - no bagels, no refund on the online order and lost a reward This is single-handedly the worst food service operation I have ever repeatedly gone to. At this point, I am the insane one for thinking they will ever get anything right. Food: 3/5 | Service: 1/5 | A... read more

Benny P. 

on Google

3 weeks ago

This amateur hour operation runs out of bagels with HOURS left of operating hours constantly. If this is a bagel shop, why run out of bagels by noon? Make more. Do your jobs. Or close shop. Simple as that. Update 2/10/26 - another wasted trip. No bagels 

Luis Zabala 

on Google

a month ago

I honestly would give them five stars but you have to make your own specialty drink like the Brooklyn egg cream. No ingredient list, no portions, just an empty cup with a spoon. Next you’ll hand me a packet of cream cheese to make my own bagel. Smh