The Old Bay Restaurant's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

The Old Bay Restaurant

4.2

About this business

Come out Friday night 15th of Janurary to see Amber Blues performing songs from their upcoming second CD as well as some classics and cover songs spanning Queen, Billy Joel and a few surprises. Show is 21+ over and band comes on at 10:30PM. 

Location details

61 Church St, # 63, New Brunswick, NJ, 08901, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon4:00 p.m. to Midnight
Tue4:00 p.m. to Midnight
Wed4:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m.
Thu4:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m.
Fri4:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m.
Sat4:00 p.m. to 2:00 a.m.
SunClosed
4.2258 reviews
Select a rating
Kristen Kane's profile image
Kristen Kane 
7 years ago

Stuffed pork chops were excellent. My Caesar salad had way too much dressing and was served on a warm plate. Service was ok, but nothing special. 

Business response:

While I'm so glad you loved the stuffed pork chops, Kristen, I'm sorry to hear the Caesar salad was a bit overdressed and if service was lacking at all. I hope to make it up to you on your next visit with the friendly and attentive service I'm sure we can provide. Thank you! -Anthony T., Business Owner 

Crystal McDonagh's profile image
Crystal McDonagh 
7 years ago

The food was excellent. The drinks were great. Bartenders were amazing. DJ Kava was spiking he was so super dope. Loved his set!!!! 

Melissa Reina Passero's profile image
Melissa Reina Passero 
7 years ago

Atmosphere, service and live music was okay but the food wasn't at all. 

Business response:

While I'm glad that you were a fan of our atmosphere, service, and live music, Melissa, it's disappointing to hear our food wasn't a highlight, too. We're known for our fresh and flavorful Cajun-inspired dishes, so I'm sorry if you didn't enjoy your meal. I hope you'll consider giving it another try, as I'm sure we can find you a dish you'll love. Thanks! -Anthony T., Business Owner 

Michelle Kay's profile image
Michelle Kay 
7 years ago

Food is amazing and staff is great most of the time. But found it near impossible to get served food within an hour of closing the kitchen. The waitress put out order in to come back 20 min later to tell us the cook refuses to make anymore food because he's closing for the night. Either you are over working one chef or he's a jerk because that's not right that we were made to wait then to be let down. The waitress seemed extremely stressed out as well. I hope this isnt a routine thing for you guys. 

Business response:

Hey Michelle, can you let us know what night you were in when this happened? That's not our style. We never let anyone leave hungry. Please let us know. 

Kurt Kvist's profile image
Kurt Kvist 
7 years ago

Great food , beer and atmosphere. Especially enjoy Mardi gra 

Business response:

I'm glad you're a fan of our food, beer, and atmosphere, Kurt, and I hope that means we'll be seeing you again soon. Cheers! -Anthony T., Business Owner 

Christopher Kelly's profile image
Christopher Kelly 
8 years ago

Great food, great staff, great music. I'd come back for a Sazerac or a Hurricane anytime. 

Business response:

I'm thrilled that you were a fan of everything, Christopher, and that our Hurricane cocktail will bring you back for more -- cheers! -Anthony T., Business Owner 

Martin Yee's profile image
Martin Yee 
8 years ago

What a great atmosphere here.....we showed up at 4:30 when the kitchen wasn't even open and they sat us anyway. Ask for Jake, he was an amazing waiter. Overall we had a great warm reception and had some amazing gumbo and po boys. 

Business response:

I'm so glad that you were happy with Jake's service, Martin, and that the gumbo and po boys were a hit too! I hope that means you'll be by again soon. Thanks! -Anthony T., Business Owner 

Janice Wojcik's profile image
Janice Wojcik 
8 years ago

This is a great place! If it was a little closer to home, I am sure I'd be here quite often. The food was fabulous..... Balanced, fresh, wide selection, large portions. The Creole sauce is very well made. It doesn't have much heat, which is good for those who prefer it mild. There were 3 different hot sauces on the table (Chipotle, Serrano, and Habanero), so you can add the level of heat you prefer. I want to put the green Serrano hot sauce on everything I eat from now on, because it was SO tasty LOL!!! Our server Veronica w... read more

Business response:

This just made my day, Janice! I'm so glad that you enjoyed your first meal with us and that you were a fan of our Creole sauce -- and the Serrano hot sauce! What's more, it's great to know our service was a hit too. That said, I'm sorry about your second cocktail! You're right, we would have been more than happy to get it sorted out, so I hope if that ever does happen again, that you'll let us know. I really can't wait to have you guys back, and maybe you'll get to check out some live music next time! Until then -- cheers! ... read more

Leon Lawson's profile image
Leon Lawson 
8 years ago

Celebrating my wife and her twin sisters bdays made reservations for 6pm Saturday which they had open. Saturday afternoon had to push it back by an hour which they were very accommodating. Saturday is busy so i didnt anticipate difficulty in parking but found a spot in Hyatt Hotel pRking garage. Now we were late but I appreciate that we were still seated promptly. Atmosphere is great and food is good. We'll be back 

Frequently asked questions about The Old Bay Restaurant

How is The Old Bay Restaurant rated?

The Old Bay Restaurant has a 4.2 star rating with 258 reviews. 

When is The Old Bay Restaurant open?

The Old Bay Restaurant is open now. It will close tomorrow at 2:00 a.m.  

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com