That's Amore Italian Cafe's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

That's Amore Italian Cafe

4.6

About this business

Even during the rare moments when you are the sum total of the cafe's clientele, this eatery always seems to buzz with activity. Warm and inviting, you will come early and stay late, as there is no pressure to leave before your conversation has run its course. Diners should make a beeline for a seat facing the back. Normally not the first choice in many restaurants but here it means an absolutely spectacular view of Seattle. Pastas and gourmet pizza flood the menu; with an excellent, modestly priced Lemon Fettuccine. There i... read more

Location details

1425 31st Ave S, Seattle, WA, 98144, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
4.6528 reviews
Select a rating
Mary D.'s profile image
8 years ago

I love eating here. Always great food & Service. We always come here for special family occasions. Love that it is a small family restaurant and not a big chain. 

vintagemary's profile image
vintagemary 
14 years ago

Wonderful Dinner for 43 – We held a wedding rehearsal dinner at That's Amore that was a big success. Chef Paul is a terrific cook and his staff were very congenial and attentive. We have received lots of compliments on the dinner and will visit the cafe often. If they have the wild boar ragu on the menu, go for it! 

user2008's profile image
user2008 
15 years ago

The Worst Customer Service Experience Ever – My husband and I went there for brunch around a month ago. We've been to this place twice before and were pretty satisfied overall. I am not sure what happened this time. May be the management changed... The waiter was so rude, we could not believe it. He looked like he was doing us a huge favor by serving us. Never came to ask how the food was; did not refill tea pot; when asked why we had only 3 sausage links and not 4 as the menu showed, he did not answer and just went back to ... read more

Business response:

Hi there user2008, we profusely apologize for your experience. When you run and operate a restaurant like ours an experience like that seems so foreign to us. I can't imagine that happening at That's Amore Italian Restaurant. But we apologize none the less and want to make it up to you. Fortunately for us, our focus on our food and customer service has made That's Amore a very popular spot, even in this down turn. 

rswenon's profile image
15 years ago

Great Food, Great View – It's worth the drive to go to That's Amore. Though it's a wonderful neighborhood place, the quality of the food makes it a pleasure to bring friends. Call ahead to reserve one of the view tables. It's a terrific angle on Seattle. 

Business response:

Hello rswenson, thank you so much for your wonderful review of That's Amore, we truly appreciate it. That is what inspired us from the beginning - great Italian food, home cooked, with amazing views of Seattle in a really cool neighborhood. We're glad you enjoyed the experience. Cheers - the team at That's Amore Italian Restaurant & Cafe 

jooz's profile image
15 years ago

This is now one of my favorites – My wife and I tried this place and loved it. We will difinately be going back. The food, sefvice and view were terrific-just what we need to make it a great night. Try it ouT 

Business response:

Thank you so much for your kind review of That's Amore Italian Restaurant in Seattle - we truly appreciate it. We look forward to serving you again sometime soon. Sincerely, the team at That's Amore 

ConvertibleGirl's profile image
ConvertibleGirl 
16 years ago

Absolutely delicious pastas and brunch - best Eggs Benedict anywhere! – My family and friends have all eaten at this great hidden gem of an Italian cafe over the years - we have never been disappointed! On one special occasion, Chef (and owner) Paul McMillion served our large group an incredible 'family style' Italian dinner - this was several years ago, and I still remember this divine meal! Scrumptious pasta, the steak with fresh tomato and wine sauce was especially good. Service has always been friendly and timely, ingred... read more

DesignVal's profile image
DesignVal 
16 years ago

Delicious food in a quaint setting with a beautiful view! – They know their food here! I ate at That's Amore! with a group of friends on a summer evening. We enjoyed a beautiful evening sunset while mmmmmmming & oooohhing over the yummy food. It's a great place to go before a night out on the town in Downtown Seattle. If I lived closer, I would go there more often. I recommend this restaurant to my friends and family...I even take them there! 

south_seattle's profile image
south_seattle 
17 years ago

Just OK – We had dinner at That's Amore tonight based on some of the reviews here and my craving for Italian food. We were ?under-whelmed? to be honest. The staff was nice and we were seated right away (the place was pretty empty but we were early for a Friday night). The view of downtown is awesome. The menu has a good selection and the prices are very reasonable. We did not have to wait too long for the food to be served and everything was hot. However, the food was simply bland - it wasn't bad but it wasn't great either. ... read more

Business response:

Thank you for your comments on your dining experience at That's Amore. We were a little surprised to hear "bland" since the sheer volume of fresh herbs and ingredients we use typically makes every dish MORE than flavorful. Please respond to us at chef_mac@msn.com with your email and we'll gladly extend an invitation I think you will be pleased with. You are one of two negative comments in all the comments we've had on the web, so I'm hoping this reaches you and I can get a response just from you. Thanks, Dawn (co-owner). 

oliviad4's profile image
17 years ago

great food great veiws great service! very cute place 

Frequently asked questions about That's Amore Italian Cafe

How is That's Amore Italian Cafe rated?

That's Amore Italian Cafe has a 4.6 star rating with 528 reviews. 

When is That's Amore Italian Cafe open?

That's Amore Italian Cafe is open now. It will close at 6:00 p.m.  

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com