Rotolo's Pizza's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Rotolo's Pizza

4.6

About this business

Operational for more than 30 years, Rotolo's Pizza is a casual dining restaurant that offers small, medium and large pizzas. The restaurant serves pizzas with various toppings, such as beef, sausage, pepperoni, ham, black olives, anchovies and mushrooms. It offers catering for various occasions, such as business luncheons, company meetings, picnics, weddings, showers, and class and family reunions,. Rotolo's Pizza also provides breadsticks, cheese sticks, potato wedges, and garlic and cheese breads. The restaurant additional... read more

Location details

1749 W 5th Ave, Columbus, OH, 43212, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
4.6418 reviews
Select a rating
Mke Gpa's profile image
15 years ago

Great Food - Pizza and Pasta – Love to get a Lasagna dinnner, with salad and roll and get a small pep pizza for dessert. That's amore'. 

Matthew4694's profile image
Matthew4694 
15 years ago

You can officially add Rotolo's Pizza to the ever-expanding list of food institutions in Columbus that have turned on their loyal customers and sold us down the corporate-restaurant river. Like Donato's Pizza, Bob Evans Restaurants and W.G. Grinders before them, Rotolo's has decided that more locations with higher prices, lower quality and minimal service are the best way to reward customers who helped drive their success for over 30 years. I have been going to Rotolo's for the last 20 years and my most recent visit has conf... read more

nafnala's profile image
16 years ago

Fabulous pizza! – We always order from the Worthington location and have never been disappointed. Wonderful pizza every time! Always fresh ingredients and always ready or delivered on time. One of the top two pizza joints in Columbus! 

nailzuz's profile image
16 years ago

Nothing Special – The pasta, and roll were just average. The pizza itself was ok. It was very raw tasting in the middle. They almost put too much sauce so that the pizza doesn't cook properly. On the very first slice literally all the cheese and toppings fell off. They do however give you a decent amount to feed at least 3. 

brownii's profile image
17 years ago

Best Baked rigatoni!!!! – Try the baked rigatoni...they bake that great pizza cheese thru out ... I heard about it word of mouth It reminds me of the baked ziti I use to get in New York!!!!!!! Yummy Yummy 

Bagel0214's profile image
Bagel0214 
17 years ago

Terrible Italian food – This is by far the worst meal I've had in at least a year. I ordered take-out. Although it was not busy, it took them 30 minutes to get me my order after being told it would only take five. I ordered the spaghetti which was undercooked and slathered in the worst sauce I've ever tasted. A note: heavy salt does not make up for lack in taste! The mushrooms in the sauce were chewy and tasteless. The order came with two rolls, one of which was so stale I couldn't eat it! 

BradyQuinn's profile image
BradyQuinn 
17 years ago

Not Anymore – Used to be good, not anymore. Raised their prices and the food got worse. Disappointed 

James614's profile image
James614 
17 years ago

The worst Italian food I?ve ever had. – Order carry out for myself and my two sons. I had the lasagna. The boys had the Italian subs. The lasagna, by far was the worst lasagna. I have ever had. The bottom noodles were overcooked. The sauce was unforgettable bad. By two sons did not like the Italian subs. We suggest if you?re looking for good Italian Ratolo?s is not the place to go. 

yompton1's profile image
yompton1 
17 years ago

No such thing as bad pizza, so to speak... – Since relocating from the northern part of the state, I've yet to find a great pizza joint. This one, like all the other local Columbus favorites, features flat, flaky pastry crust. Very boring. What is this town's obsession with cutting round pizzas into square slices?? It's round because it is a pizza PIE. Cut it like one! 

Frequently asked questions about Rotolo's Pizza

How is Rotolo's Pizza rated?

Rotolo's Pizza has a 4.6 star rating with 418 reviews. 

When is Rotolo's Pizza open?

Rotolo's Pizza is open now. It will close at 6:00 p.m.  

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com