Pizzeria Eataly's cover image

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Pizzeria Eataly

2.3

About this business

Location details

1214 Boardwalk, Ocean City, NJ, 08226, United States

Get directions
2.338 reviews
Select a rating
Steve Brule's profile image
Steve Brule 
a month ago

Update: Pizzeria englehart is no more, so Dan Drangle whipped up a little poem, called: Ode to Pizzeria Englehart Blue cactus was no more, So a new pizza joint came to the shore. Pizzeria englehart was its name, Seeking boardwalk notoriety and fame. Pizza, hot dogs, even bagels you might find, A wild adventure awaited anyone who dined. Disheveled and dirty was their cooking space, Hygiene was hit and miss at this place. With gloves on, they’d scratch their head, Then dive right back into kneading bread. The prices did them n... read more

Chris Ryan's profile image
Chris Ryan 
8 months ago
Sandy Lewis's profile image
Sandy Lewis 
11 months ago

I also wish I had read reviews before going here. We were charged almost $28 for a small meatless Caesar Salad and a Bacon Egg and Cheese Bagel -- both mediocre. I understand "resort pricing", but at least deliver quality if you are going to charge those prices. The bagel sandwich had completely soggy, under-cooked bacon. All the worker would have had to do was pop it in the microwave for a minute to cook it more. When I told her on the way out, the Eastern European worker all of a sudden could not understand English. Also, ... read more

Olivia Saunders's profile image
Olivia Saunders 
11 months ago

I wish I had read the reviews instead of just picking a place that "looked good". Food was overpriced for what you get. Smoked Salmon bagel had barely any salmon on it. Employees looked like they hated their jobs. Based on that probably would have been a 3... but as we were finishing eating we watched the cook scratch her head with her gloves on... and continue making food. Then with the same gloves she started cleaning tables and things in the kitchen. I don't know if she ever changed her gloves becauase we left. 

Michael Espejo's profile image
Michael Espejo 
11 months ago

One of the worst meals I've ever paid for. An avacado hot dog had some type of avacado paste. Nothing about it was good. A corn dog seemed old and was burnt. Asked for no sour cream on nachos. Came with sour cream and pickles. Who in the world puts pickles on nachos? Stay away! Photos are Not what they are serving. 

Frequently asked questions about Pizzeria Eataly

How is Pizzeria Eataly rated?

Pizzeria Eataly has a 2.3 star rating with 38 reviews. 

When is Pizzeria Eataly open?

Pizzeria Eataly is permanently closed. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com