Pick Your Pie's cover image
Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Pick Your Pie

4.6

About this business

A new pie concept! Instead of a traditional slice of pie, you can have your pie in a cup, crepe or with dessert chips. YOU pick the crust, filling and topping to create your own combination of pie. All of our crusts, fillings, sauces and whipped cream are made from scratch on site. 

Location details

5815B Mayfield Rd, Mayfield Heights, OH, 44124, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
4.648 reviews
Select a rating
Richard Douglass's profile image
Richard Douglass 
10 years ago

Too many calories but couldn't resist. Will get the regular size next time, not the large. Very tasty. 

John Comella's profile image
John Comella 
10 years ago
Liz Williams Tilton's profile image
Liz Williams Tilton 
10 years ago

Fantastic pies!! Even my non-pie eating kids LOVED it!!! 

Nick Lanzara's profile image
Nick Lanzara 
10 years ago

This place is the BEST!!!! Great idea...my kids love it 

CJ Blakely's profile image
CJ Blakely 
10 years ago
Carlos White's profile image
Carlos White 
10 years ago

Amazing !! 

Kristy Saar-Horrocks's profile image
Kristy Saar-Horrocks 
10 years ago
Jim Greer's profile image
Jim Greer 
10 years ago
Katherine Nemeth's profile image
Katherine Nemeth 
10 years ago

I visited just recently and ordered the chocolate cream pie with graham cracker crust and toasted coconut. Delicious combination. All fresh ingredients made from scratch. I will definitely return and tell friends to try it! 

Frequently asked questions about Pick Your Pie

How is Pick Your Pie rated?

Pick Your Pie has a 4.6 star rating with 48 reviews. 

When is Pick Your Pie open?

Pick Your Pie is closed now. It will open tomorrow at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com