Mexitaly's cover image
Claimed

This profile has been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Mexitaly

4.4

About this business

When you combine foods from two great cultures, there's no shortage of flavor. That's why our owner, Greg, fused his Italian heritage with his love of Mexican food when he started Mexitaly. Enjoy each cuisine on its own or mix them together -- your taste buds are sure to thank you either way. Our creative juices don't just influence our food, though. Rick, our brewmaster, keeps a steady rotation of some of the best craft beers around. Even better, each one is brewed in house. Couple our unique menu with our live music nights... read more

Location details

2440 E Market St, Yorklyn, PA, 17402, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
4.41,475 reviews
Select a rating
Sandi Wagner Allmond's profile image
Sandi Wagner Allmond 
10 years ago

Yummy ;-) and a new favorite! 

Phil Garrett's profile image
Phil Garrett 
10 years ago

One of our favorite places in York. Very good food but the cheap plastic utensils have got to go! 

Business response:

your wish is about to come true philly! 

James C. Lynn's profile image
James C. Lynn 
11 years ago

5 out of 5 stars 

Business response:

james, i figured this was an issue which i could not reverse and any attempts at consolation would be futile. however, i remember the situation and while i was inquisitive about where you got the bottle there in no way was an accusation of "stealing". we have bottles at the front counters by the registers which were clearly labeled as for sale which people were taking for use at the tables. while it is a minor annoyance that people don't read signs i was in no way angry. when i would see one at a table i would ask where take... read more

Matthew Smith's profile image
Matthew Smith 
11 years ago

Mexitaly is one of york pa hidden diamonds. I have eaten many of the items on the menu and have never been disappointed. So please give this great diamond of food a try :-) :-) 

Susan Borja's profile image
Susan Borja 
11 years ago

Excellent 

Melanie Johnson's profile image
Melanie Johnson 
11 years ago

Ate here yesterday. Buffalo chicken pizza and chicken Cesar salad was amazing!!! 

Mary Windschmitt's profile image
Mary Windschmitt 
11 years ago

Best Mexican & Italian food around. Always a great experience. Food is fresh, consistent and full of flavor. Love it! 

Vincent Clemente's profile image
Vincent Clemente 
11 years ago

So good! 

Christian Mitchell's profile image
Christian Mitchell 
11 years ago

Ordered a stromboli and waited over a half hour to get it. When I went to see what was going on the guy said it takes over 20 minutes to make one. I said I've been waiting for over 30. Then he says they haven't started it anyway and asks me if I want to wait another 30. Not the nicest gentlemen either. Walked away with a refund and a wasted half hour. 

Business response:

christian...the offer to make it right still stands. print out the emailed response and give us another go. 

Frequently asked questions about Mexitaly

How is Mexitaly rated?

Mexitaly has a 4.4 star rating with 1,475 reviews. 

When is Mexitaly open?

Mexitaly is closed now. It will open tomorrow at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com