Gib's On the Lake

Chris Boschetti 

on Google

3 weeks ago

Great atmosphere and lake view. Service was not overly friendly. Food was ok - shrimp was overcooked, and steak served was not the steak ordered, but their french onion soup was very good. 

Adam Koskubar 

on Google

2 months ago

The soup and appetizers were amazing. Waiting for 2 hours to eat after our reservations was a little much. For what we paid for the prime rib it should have melted im my mouth. It was very stringy almost flavorless and for the most part one of the tougher ones I've had. For the amount of money spent here I would have thought we would have received an all around better experience. This was the first and last time going there. 

Gretchen Shimek 

on Google

2 months ago

Lobster and shrimp bisque was brown. Tasted all right but you eat with your eyes first and being served brown soup was not fun. Fried shrimp was decent, fries were brown and not seasoned. Bread basket had 4 tiny slices and two pads of butter. My husband had sirloin and ordered with with mushrooms and onions which were forgotten. And brought out 3-5 min later. His steak was ordered med rare and was different temps all the way through. His salad was decent. 

Neil DeSimone 

on Google

3 months ago

I’ve been coming to this place for over 30+ while en-route to Sturgeon Bay. We exit the interstate just to come to Gibbs. I have never had a bad meal in over 20-30 dinners, most likely more. I read some of these other reviews and some people just have to complain about something.Again, this place is amazing.