Geneva Gelato

NYC MOF 

on Google

3 weeks ago

I had to pull over to give this place it's Million Star review!!!! I'm from NYC. Moved to outskirts of Buffalo. I used to get Gelato from my local pizza guy Sal. May he Rest in Peace. I used to go in the back and watch Sal make Gelato. I got addicted to the chocolate. I had to come to Geneva today to my job. I saw the Geneva Gelato sign in the window and was like NO!!!! Made that U Turn immediately and park out front. Was a comfortable atmosphere inside. I can tell it was a legit place. Not some dirty, second hand shop. I... read more

Tmoney 

on Google

2 years ago

Great little gem! The Gelato was amazing. I got an iced mocha that could easily rival the main chains. I will definitely go out of my way for a place like this. The atmosphere was causal, yet professional. Can't forget to mention the selection of baked goods too. 

Derek Bryant 

on Google

3 years ago

A must visit place if you're in Geneva! Try the macarons, try the gelato, try the coffee, try the cheesecake. It's all delicious. This is the first place I've found real gelato outside of Rome in a long time. It's all reasonably priced. I will need to go back to try more of their cakes and smoothies. Thanks to the owner, Jeff, for a fun conversation as well. 

Laura Henry 

on Google

3 years ago

I had high hopes for Geneva Gelato, but I was disappointed. I found Geneva Gelato via the Happy Cow app and was excited to see that they had vegan options. I ordered the Peanut Butter Cookie and Chocolate flavors (both vegan). Both of these flavors were the final bits that were left in the tray/bucket. The Chocolate had a lot of ice crystals/freezer burn. The Peanut Butter Cookie had good flavor, but had that sticky, syrupy texture that can happen when ice creams have been sitting a bit or when they are down to the last... read more

Eric Haffner 

on Google

3 years ago

Authentic gelato and friendly service. Prices are a little higher than your normal ice cream shop, but remember - it’s not ice cream, it’s gelato. The black raspberry was very good.