Dr. Neil S. Rosenthal, MD

Andrew 

on Healthgrades

7 years ago

Dr. Rosenthal's office accommodated quick appointment turnarounds. Dr. Rosenthal himself is friendly, kind, informative and to the point. He makes you feel at ease despite the diagnosis, positive or negative. Highly recommended specialist. 

Anonymous 

on Healthgrades

7 years ago

I was really nervous when I arrived, but I was relieved to find the doctor to be understanding, knowledgeable, sympathetic, and he was on time for my visit. He asked tons of questions and was very thorough. I felt very comfortable with him and am so happy that I found him. The staff was really organize and caring. I was very satisfied with my visit and highly recommend this doctor. 

Anonymous 

on Healthgrades

7 years ago

I find it hard to believe that any of the positive reviews are true. This doctor is rude, and his level of knowledge is less than any other medical professional I have had. I would never recommend him and if you are using him I highly recommend trying someone else. He runs his office like a failing business desperate to grab every dollar he can. He does not have a bedside manner unless you liked to be talked down to about your own body and health. He is a terrible doctor. 

Karen 

on Healthgrades

8 years ago

Thorough and not overly reactive. I've gone in with numerous "small" complaints - a neurologist is almost a primary care physician, in that he can diagnose and treat all sorts of ailments. Very attentive and responsive. I've recommended him to many friends, all of whom are pleased. 

Anonymous 

on Healthgrades

8 years ago

I found Dr. Rosenthal on Zocdoc and went in for a consultation for numbness in my hand. He determined through very extensive testing that I'd had a mild stroke--something my primary doctor missed--and started me on the correct course of treatment ASAP. He even contacted my primary to discuss the oversight. His office manager Nicole stayed late to book me an emergency MRI and on one occasion helped me to get a test done when Dr. Rosenthal's office was closed. These people listen and they care!!! 

JD 

on Healthgrades

8 years ago

Every patient arrives with different needs. The unique nature of each visit tends to create reviews so specific that they offer little guidance, good or bad. Dr. Rosenthal, however, has mastered those exceptional qualities universally desired by all in need of help. He is Sympathetic, Intelligent, and Effective; inspiring confidence that problems can be treated and better days will come. Nicole, who does everything the Doctor doesn't, is a friendly voice and a great help! 

Alan R. Siegel. 

on Healthgrades

8 years ago

I have been a patient of Dr. Rosenthal for many years. He is a warm caring very competent physician who was recommended to me by a retired surgeon. Several years ago I had severe back problems and Dr. Rosenthal arranged for me to immediately see a neurosurgeon at Weill Cornell. Two days later I was operated upon and two months later I was playing tennis again. The office is small with his very competent assistant, Nicole, handling the administrative tasks. Dr. Rosenthal works on a timely basis. 

Arthur Hunnewell 

on Healthgrades

8 years ago

I first met Dr. Rosenthal in December 2012 for my diabetic neuropathy. I found his initial evaluation and assessment to be very helpful and insightful. I have continued to see him for my neuropathy ever since. Either on a quarterly or semi-annual basis, depending upon how the neuropathy in my feet and lower legs is progressing. His office administrator has been very helpful with insurance, making appointments and reminding me when my next appointment is. I strongly endorse his medical services 

Troy 

on Healthgrades

8 years ago

After suffering from cluster headaches for years, Dr. Rosenthal diagnosed and treated them effectively. He called me back within an hour on more than one occasion when I had questions about my treatment. He is extremely intelligent, dedicated, and professional. I enthusiastically recommend him.