Dr. Benjamin Overley

Walter Jones 

on Google

2 months ago

Dr. Overley at Island Foot and Ankle Surgery provided exceptional care during my treatment journey for foot and toe pain. I initially visited him two years ago, and after assessing my condition, he recommended surgery and a fusion. Despite the lengthy decision-making process where I scheduled, then canceled surgery, I continued to endure significant pain. When I finally returned to Dr. Overley, he once again recommended surgery and again took the time to explain the procedure and recovery process in detail, accurately predic... read more

Logan Combs 

on Google

10 months ago

Office is old and falling apart, long wait times, hardly answer phones 

Christy Gail 

on Google

11 months ago

Dr. Overley used to be an attentive, skilled surgeon — someone I trusted for multiple procedures. But something has clearly changed. When complications arose, he became unreachable and stopped responding entirely. I asked for help, and was ignored. Instead of follow-up care, I received blame-shifting and silence. Worse, his staff has been unprofessional and dismissive — even going so far as to harass female patients who ask for answers. I was met with gaslighting, false assumptions, and an overwhelming sense that they were p... read more

M 

on Google

11 months ago

Was dealing with toe pain and swelling in my great right toe for months. Finally looked into a podiatrist and came across Dr Overly here on the island. Being in the medical field, you are always extra careful on who you choose for a surgeon. While he did not recommend surgery immediately (and appreciative of that), the scans ended up showing my condition had limited options. I went through with a right great toe osteotomy, along with the sesamoid bones needing to be moved back into the proper place. Two screws later, and bei... read more