Ben Garelick is a family-owned jewelry store that has been proudly providing engagement rings, wedding bands, and other fine jewelry to the Western New York community for over 65 years. Specializing in bridal rings, Ben Garelick offers a wide variety of diamond shapes and sizes. From antique and vintage to unique and contemporary, Ben Garelick will have a ring that suits your wishes, desires, and budget. Our expert jewelers will ensure that you find the perfect ring with the most sparkling diamonds, moissanite, or gemstones, and will answer any questions you have in selecting your perfect engagement ring or gift. Find the diamond you love for the one you love. Browse our full collection onli

Suggest edits

BIRDEYE FOR BUSINESSES

This profile is powered by Birdeye. Over 100,000 businesses use Birdeye everyday to get more reviews and manage all customer feedback. Birdeye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Learn more about Birdeye

5.0

★★

1,655 reviews

5★908

4★10

3★0

2★1

1★2

734 reviews have no rating

Reviews(784)

Google Reviews(871)

Sort By:

Featured

Melissa Tambroni-Szymanski on Facebook

3 years ago

Excellent customer service!!! Beautiful quality jewelry!!

Business Response:

Thank you so much! ❤

James J. Joy on Facebook

5 years ago

Lee Sobieski on Facebook

5 years ago

Featured content

Trust Economy: Why Google and Birdeye Are Against Review Gating

Livechat vs chatbot: which one is right for your business?

James J. Joy on Facebook

★★

5 years ago

Lee Sobieski on Facebook

★★

5 years ago

Rory O'Hagan on Facebook

5 years ago

These guys were amazing to deal with. No hard sell, no up-sell, just very honest, incredibly patient and always quick to respond to my endless questions. Peter worked with me over a span of months while I wavered on making up my mind (it's a big decision!) and gave me options and different ideas. In the end he found a way to make my top choice happen, within my budget! I was thrilled with their treatment of me and would recommend them to anyone. These guys care about making YOU happy. On top of all that, their ring selection is incredible. Whatever you may be looking for, they're sure to have it. The ring I selected I had scoured relentlessly and found nothing even close to it before coming across their website. Could not be happier with the ring or my treatment! Make it easy on yourself, and go to BG for your jewelry needs!

Christine Platz on Facebook

★★

5 years ago

Passing my father’s St. Christopher medal to my son was very special. They did a beautiful job cleaning the medal and helping me choose a chain that was hardy enough for a teenager. Service was wonderful and they truly identified with the sentiment of my purchase. Thank you!

Business Response:

Christine, thank you for the lovely review. We understand that jewelry has sentimental value far greater than monetary value, and we are so happy we could help you.

Shannon Shaw Lisicki on Facebook

★★

5 years ago

Fantastic experience! Peter Sr. was our salesperson and he was wonderful to work with. Knowledgeable, respectful, super friendly with a great sense of humor! I loved that he wasn’t pushy and let me take my time with every piece he showed me. I am extremely happy with the piece I chose and would recommend them to anyone. Thanks so much… I’ll be back!!

Business Response:

Shannon, thank you for your review! We're so glad you appreciate both Peter's sense of humor and the experience of purchasing with us. We look forward to working with you again!

Juan Parra on Facebook

5 years ago

Excellent communication with them, I'm impressed by the ring and the center stone they're amazing I love it.

Get more reviews. Get more customers.

Get more reviews from your customers with Birdeye. Dominate search results. Beat local competitors. Grow your business. Easy, done.

GET MORE REVIEWS BOOK A TIME