Trattoria Caterina

ericaheitke 

on Citysearch

16 years ago

I probably would not go here again. – They had a rather cheap atmosphere, but good bread. I didn't really care for any of their soups. There chicken tasted dry and cheap and kinda stringy. There alfredo sauce was unique, but I think Olive Garden's is way better. Their's was very thin. They did have excellent shrimp though and I really enjoyed my shrimp fettucine with mushrooms in garlic wine sauce (custom order). For dessert I had Tiramisu. It was ok. The cheese part was excellent, but it lacked coffee flavor and needed more... read more

M E. 

on Insider Pages

16 years ago

Not so great maybe my expectations were too high, but it was just ok. Not great. First for romance, not your place. Too bright, no ambiance, should put candles on the table and dim the overhead lights. As for dinner, I got a shrimp dish, pasta, a "cream sauce'. It lacked flavor and was more like someone put cornstarch in broth. Then, it's great that it's BYOB but they charge you a fee for bringing wine and for having bread. Weird. I wouldn't go again or recommend. 

Mike O. 

on Insider Pages

16 years ago

inconsistent quality and service The first time we went there we were charmed by the atmosphere and the service was family-friendly. The food was great and we looked forward to going back. Every other time that we went there, the service was poor and the food was lacking in quality. 

Valerie Moloney 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

South Loopers remain faithful to this neighborhood BYOB serving Italian standards. – The Scene While its name hints at a romantic dining spot, this trattoria is more of a place to catch up with old friends. The lighting is just a tad too bright to play up romance, but that doesn't take away from the restaurant's intimacy and charm. Thirty- and fortysomethings take their time enjoying every sip of wine at white-linen topped tables in neutral-toned, L-shaped and neighboring dining rooms, while never harried servers make it a p... read more

flygood99 

on Citysearch

18 years ago

Amazing Food, Great Service, extremely relaxing place – This restaurant is truly italian. They allow you time to truly enjoy their extraordinary food. I eat fetticini alfredo at every italian restaurant I try, and I can say with out a doubt this was the best I've ever had. This coupled with the conveniance of a BYOB policy, makes this one of the best Italian spots in Chicago. 

jameslo 

on Citysearch

21 years ago

great low key neighborhood italian – A low key comfortable setting does not require you to dress up very much. We had the grilled calamari, chicken, and seafood pastas. All excellent. The entrees come with either a soup or salad. Overall, a very nice and relaxing dinner at a reasonable price for the downtown area. We will definitely be revisiting. And we found out you can bring your own bottle of wine.