Tosco's Pizzeria New Windsor

Paden's Place 

on Google

a week ago

This USED to be the undisputed pizza king of New Windsor. Then the old man died and whichever kid took over has let it rot. The tables are horrific, broken, and dirty every time I've stepped inside. The pizza is chewy. The staff looks like they'd rather be anywhere else, and I don't blame them so do I. 

Nino Legend 

on Google

a month ago

I've been a customer here for a very long time. Today, some girl that's manning the phone ruined it all in 3 minutes. She must hate her job or the owner. No problem, there are many other places to order from. 

Tony Ricci 

on Google

a month ago

My pizzas where on top of oven with in 10 min of calling had to recut the pies heated up slice pies not made to order? Soft crust no flaver 

Jules Olsen 

on Google

a month ago

My boyfriend and I have been customers at all the Tosco’s locations for about 10 years. It was our go-to place together and apart. About a year ago we stopped going because it seemed like the food had gone down in quality, but a month ago we decided to try it out again. The first time we went back we ordered one of our old favorites, the crazy chicken roll, which has chicken cutlet and a variety of sauces inside to make a “crazy” sauce. The woman on the phone seemed confused about our pick, but figured out a way to put it in... read more