Sweet Melissa's Cafe

Cathy Carr 

on Google

a year ago

I'm giving the food a 3 because the cheesecake and smokey manhattan were wonderful. Redfish entree very salty. Swordfish entree just okay. Very industrial atmosphere and odd table layout. Spotty service! Not what I expected for upscale dining. 

Zack Diamond 

on Google

a year ago

My wife and I were excited to return to Sweet Melissas after hearing the great news of their reopening in a new off-island space. It’s always a joy to see a beloved local gem back in business, and we were eager to experience what the new location had to offer. However, while I’m thrilled that Sweet Melissa is back, the overall execution and flavor of many of the dishes fell short of our expectations, especially compared to the high standards set by pre-Ian Sweet Melissas. We started with the Lamb Meatballs with Whipped Feta ... read more

Linda Matchette 

on Google

a year ago

This is an amazing place but is not open at the current time. Jan & Feb 2025 There is a sign in front of a vacant lot saying coming soon. Just a FYI 

Jennifer Butterfield 

on Google

a year ago

I've been going to Sweet Melissa's Cafe since it opened on Sanibel in 2009, but this is the first time I've left a review. Melissa's food is incredible. Always fresh, season, and fabulous. And hee staff is always so friendly and attentive. Tonight, my mom and I shared the watermelon and heirloom tomato salad (empty plate, oops :). And I had the pork belly boa buns for dinner. I don't remember seeing the buns on the menu before. They were magnificent and completely satisfying. My mom and husband always, always get the famous ... read more