Star Island Grill

Nicholas Drew 

on Google

2 weeks ago

I’ve had better food at an airport. The fish sandwich tasted freezer burned still, so I knew it was not fresh. Clam chowder was insanely questionable as well. I knew it was a red flag when the waiter said the best thing on the menu was the Caesar salad…..$60 later I left and had a second dinner elsewhere. 

Marion Seltzer 

on Google

a month ago

Informal and Great place for any meal... innovative dishes (I had the sausage and shrimp gumbo). You can travel anywhere in the world but the view out to the water and past the coast guard station is as beautiful as any place anywhere. 

sue zavags 

on Google

a month ago

The Fonz is the best! You hook'em they cook'em. High recommend! 

Agnieszka Czerkies 

on Google

2 months ago

They have "you hook them, we cook them" so every year, when we fish in Montauk, we come here to get our fish cooked and eat it. I wait all year for it because the Chef is a true professional. There are several ways he can prepare your fish (not only fried or blackened) and every single one is delicious! My favorite is asian way with seaweed salad. It's and experience not a simple meal... 

Carole Petto 

on Google

2 months ago

The view was beautiful, and the food was fabulous. We had the mussels. They were incredible. The rest of our meals were just as good. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.