Claim this profile

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

Claim this business to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Selman & Co.

3.3
Get directions

About this business

Selman & Company markets and administers life and health insurance products. It provides services to more than 65 associations and affinity groups throughout the United States. The company is a member of the American Institute of Professional Association Group Insurance Administrators and the Professional Insurance Marketing Association. It offers accident insurance programs to more than 300 credit unions and operates through over 25 independent brokerage agencies. It also serves banks and mortgage companies and other financ... read more

Location details

6110 Parkland Blvd, Mayfield Heights, OH, 44124, United States

Get directions
WeekdayScheduleStatus
Mon9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Tue9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Wed9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Thu9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Fri9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
SatClosed
SunClosed
Review Performance in the last  
6 months
3.3437 reviews
Select a rating
jolene g.'s profile image
jolene g. 
on Birdeye

2 years ago

i have been trying to get a human being to return a call from Selman & Co. for several weeks. My husband received a 1099 from them - the issue I have is he has been passed away for almost 3 years. No one will return a call to me or respond to any emails. I have no idea where the funds went to - they did not come to him at our home. If someone can tell me how I can get to a real person there it would be appreciated. 

Betty Jo T.'s profile image
Betty Jo T. 
on Birdeye

2 years ago

Rating is ZERO stars. I called Selman & Co. back in November and was told they could not locate my policy no., therefore, I contacted my bank where my premium automatic withdrawals are withdrawn on a quarterly basis. I contacted the bank and had the automatic withdrawals discontinued since the company could not find my policy which I've been paying premiums for a decade or more. I finally received a letter on 1/7/22 regarding their having not received my premium in January. I've attempted to call back on no. provided 877-... read more

Kea P.'s profile image
Kea P. 
on Birdeye

2 years ago

This company service your policy so you don’t have a choice to do business with them or not. I have a life insurance policy that started with Aetna, then transferred to Hartford which is serviced by this company, Selman. I’ve been trying to get their billing/charge error on my policy rectified for a year now since last August without success. I’ve emailed them multiple times without getting any responses back. I’ve talked to numerous service reps that tells me the same thing—I promise you I’ll look into this and call you bac... read more

Rene W.'s profile image
Rene W. 
on Birdeye

2 years ago

Don't ever do business with this company! I've tried to get my co pay drug claims paid since February. They had/have my address wrong. I updated it myself when we moved in Sept 2019 and they never can get it right. All I get from them is the Quarterly BILL but no EOB's and no checks for copay reimbursement. I've literally called 6 times since February and all I get is the run around. They said they finally have my address situation straightened out but still no checks....only bills from them. Each time I've called, th... read more

Karleen B.'s profile image
Karleen B. 
on Birdeye

2 years ago

This company is horrible. My father has a life insurance policy through them. He died March13th (3 months ago) and he had been paying on it since 1976. He never missed a payment or was never late. My family have been trying to collect on this claim since then. All we get is the run around from them. Last week we filed a complaint with the Department of Insurance against Selman & Co.. When we call once, twice a week Selman & Co always make some excuse saying they have to check with XYZ department. What a bunch of B.S. NEVER ... read more

Kim K.'s profile image
Kim K. 
on Birdeye

3 years ago

Bad company. Slow to pay providers and beneficiaries if you submit a claim, hard to get a hold of (super long waiting periods if you call them), no electronic lookup of claims like every other insurance company. Make me wonder if this company is having some financial difficulties causing them to be understaffed, and slow in payments. 

Frank T.'s profile image
Frank T. 
on Birdeye

3 years ago

Zero stars Phone hold times are unreal. 3 hours Never process paperwork.  

Jennifer F.'s profile image
Jennifer F. 
on Birdeye

4 years ago

THIS COMPANY SHOULD HAVE IT'S DOORS CLOSED!!! IT IS A SCAM TO TAKE PEOPLES MONEY. THEY WILL NEVER SEND YOU ANY INFORMATION ABOUT YOUR POLICY. THEY NEVER ANSWER THEIR PHONES AND PUT YOU ON HOLD FOREVER OR UNTIL YOU DECIDE YOU CAN NOT HOLD THE LINE ANY LONGER. THEY NEVER UPDATE YOUR INFORMATION. THEY CHANGE COMPANY NAMES SO YOU CAN NEVER TRACK THEM DOWN, SO THEREFORE THEY DO NOT HAVE TO PAY OUT CLAIMS TO YOU. I HAVE NOTICED THAT MANY VETS HAVE BEEN MISTREATED BY THEM !!! ALL THEY WANT TO DO IS TAKE YOUR MONEY FROM YOUR ACCOU... read more

Animesh B.'s profile image
Animesh B. 
on Birdeye

4 years ago

DO NOT go by any of the positive reviews - they are the few and the lucky.This company will do everything it can to delay your claim. The customer service is mind-numbingly poor. ON-HOLD TIMES ARE AT MINIMUM ONE HOUR.They blame everything on 'the computers'. They will lie and intentionally mislead you. Specifically, Yolanda and Vortiste....and the rest of the employees don't sound like they have graduated high school. Stay away for your own well-being. 

Frequently asked questions about Selman & Co.

How is Selman & Co. rated?

Selman & Co. has a 3.3 star rating with 437 reviews. 

When is Selman & Co. open?

Selman & Co. is closed now. It will open on Monday at 9:00 a.m. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com