This profile is powered by Birdeye. Over 100,000 businesses use Birdeye everyday to get more reviews and manage all customer feedback. Birdeye helps millions of local businesses to be found online with all their reviews and accurate business information. Learn more about Birdeye

4.4

★★

125 reviews

5★85

4★19

3★7

2★4

1★8

2 reviews have no rating

Reviews(10)

Google Reviews(115)

Sort By:

Featured

Kevin Christel review for Play It Again Sports

Kevin Christel on Facebook

3 years ago

HORRIBLE, NASTY STAFF. Went there around 3:15pm on Wed, 9/23/20. As I entered the store, there were 2 teenage employees behind the counter. The male said in a very terse voice “Ya want something?” When I asked to see free weight dumbbells, the female just pointed and said “Over there.” I heard another charming employee jokingly remark “That’s real customer service.” I pivoted and left. I will never go there again and encourage others to boycott the place!!!

Darin Angie Lawson review for Play It Again Sports

Darin Angie Lawson on Facebook

4 years ago

Very pleased with our transaction at PIAS, Fishers. Andrew was very pleasant to deal with in the store. He and another associate came to remove our trade-in equipment (some heavy stuff, and a treadmill), and installed the 'new' items in our basement. They were very efficient, courteous and very capable. Here's hoping the pre-owned equipment we purchased lasts a long time! ;-)

Annette Hicks review for Play It Again Sports

Annette Hicks on Facebook

★★

7 years ago

Wanna give a shot out 2 Mark he help me so much �

Featured content

Review manager vs. reputation management: what's the difference?

How can customer reviews help SEO?

Jeremy Forsyth review for Play It Again Sports

Jeremy Forsyth on Facebook

★★

7 years ago

We stopped by with my son looking for a bat one evening after dinner it was a minute or two after 8 they were closed no big deal so we started walking away a moment later someone came out and asked if he could help he let us in after hours and we got a bat. Long story short great customer service. Didn't have to do let us in but they did. Great job.

Garrett Mauk review for Play It Again Sports

Garrett Mauk on Facebook

★★

8 years ago

Amazing customer service.

C.j. Morris review for Play It Again Sports

C.j. Morris on Facebook

★★

9 years ago

Place is a joke I called prior to going and was told they would be interested in wakeboards get there and they claim that must have been the new guy that doesn't know what he is talking about...Also was told they would be interested in snowboard and snow skis which was also a lie because it isn't winter yet.very unprofessional employees

Business Response:

We strive on having great customer service and will do what we can to help you. We buy wakeboards year round if they are a newer style. We are also buying current skis and snowboards and have been for months. Call us at 317-626-6127 and we can tell you if your gear is something we can purchase.