Mid-Atlantic Stocking's cover image

This profile has not been claimed by the business owner or representative.

to update business information, get appointment requests, engage visitors with web chat, and more!

Mid-Atlantic Stocking

4.7

About this business

Location details

257 Nagel Hill Rd, Candor, NY, 13743, United States

Get directions
4.729 reviews
Select a rating
amhst56's profile image
amhst56 
2 days ago

Fish were extremely healthy and energetic when we released them. Great prices and very efficient process to get the fish. Will buy from again soon! 

Mike Toni's profile image
Mike Toni 
3 weeks ago

At 12:56pm on 3/31/26, I sent an email to Mid Atlantic Fish Stocking to get some help with an order I was attempting to place online. FOUR MINUTES LATER, at 1:00pm, I got an email response from Administrative Assistant BrieAnna who had already looked into the matter on her end and wanted me to know I could call her to work through the order. Turns out the issues I was having was entirely user error on my part and I was able to successfully place my order. A FOUR MINUTE response time to a new customer is absolutely mind boggl... read more

Bob LeMay's profile image
Bob LeMay 
10 months ago

I recently got more bluegill for my quarter acre pond.About two years old,I started stocking my pond and contacted Mid -Atlantic for a start up .I talked with Alex and he was very cordial and patient.I have called him several times since and he was very helpful.When I got another purchase of fish ,I found the driver to be courteous and professional.I found their ad in the NY Outdoor News ,a hunting/ fishing newspaper.I love their service and products.I would highly recommend Mid -Atlantic to home owners who are thinking of s... read more

Jacquelyn Eyster's profile image
Jacquelyn Eyster 
11 months ago

I recently received Koi fish in various sizes 8-10 inches and 12-14 inches and they were beautiful! The lengths vary based upon their catch! Fish were healthy, happy, and the process was super easy! There was great communication and clarification on pricing, delivery times of pickups, and the staff truly are considerate and very passionate about their jobs! The lady told me she hand selected mine and she really did a beautiful job giving me a mixed assortment! Will be returning! 

Shawn W's profile image
Shawn W 
a year ago

I bought fish from them about 2 years ago. It was 15 bass, 15 catfish, 12 bluegill and bout 200 minnows or maybe it was fatheads, but anyways i got a bunch of fish. Not really sure how everything worked and i was worry some were going to show up dead, but everything worked perfectly! I met them on their route, came home and put them in the pond. 2 years later these things are huge they had to grow over a foot since I got them! AND! In the whole time I had them I lost one catfish and that was a few days after first introducin... read more

Frequently asked questions about Mid-Atlantic Stocking

How is Mid-Atlantic Stocking rated?

Mid-Atlantic Stocking has a 4.7 star rating with 29 reviews. 

When is Mid-Atlantic Stocking open?

Mid-Atlantic Stocking is open now. It is open 24/7. 

Need help? Contact us.

Speak with a specialist to learn how you can grow with Birdeye. We are reachable at profiles@birdeye.com