Lake Geneva Pie Co

Samella Nichols 

on Google

a week ago

Staff was not friendly or welcoming! 

Kollin Asher 

on Google

2 weeks ago

I understand that some businesses don’t like to stay open or work very much but it seems odd that a breakfast and pie place is closed so often. Don’t plan on coming here when you’re off on a Sunday and finally have a day to explore. They will be closed. I even tried on a Friday and they were still closed. Then on a random week day, closed again. So I give up. They just don’t want to work. Will eat and spend money, elsewhere. 

Larry Robbins 

on Google

3 weeks ago

You can't find a better pie , so don't go here I want them all to myself. People there are also very friendly and all you look for in a business environment. Honestly they are the best people and you can't go wrong to go there 

Eddy Cevilla 

on Google

a month ago

We needed a Key Lime pie last minute and Lake Geneva Pie Company completely saved the day. They were incredibly accommodating with our short-notice request and were so kind and helpful each time we called to coordinate. When we went to get it, the pickup process was quick and completely hassle-free. Best of all, the pie itself was awesome! Hands down some of the best Key Lime pie we've ever had. Excellent customer service and top-tier baking. We will definitely be back! 

Chrissy Bertani 

on Google

a month ago

Wonderful pies, fruit, cream, pot pies, cookie, soups, and quiche’s! Can really settle a sweet tooth or savory tooth in 1 visit! Cute little quaint shop too! Staff and owner were all lovely and helpful!! We will be back! Thank goodness my sister lives near here in Wisconsin, we are from St. Louis!