Islamorada Fish Company Restaurant

BJSurrett 

on Citysearch

13 years ago

HORRIBLE service! – We have eaten here several times while visiting the store attached and the service has never been great, but our last trip was unacceptable. We are low maintenance, easy to please customers and the experience was so bad it was almost comical. Worst of all when I told the manager we had to get our own utensils and bread plates, bus our own dishes, move the food ourselves (he refused to give it to the right person), never got drink refills AND he was rude, the manager didn't care at all. No wonder the staff... read more

stingraysteiner 

on Citysearch

16 years ago

disappointing – Came here for a family reunion and to celebrate my birthday and Mother's Day. There were 15 of us. I called to make reservations but they said they didn't take any but would be ready to accomodate us. We waited 45 minutes. When the food arrived, everyone was disappointed. Two got the wrong side dishes and the fish and shrimp was dry. I ordered lobster (which came with No butter!) and had to ask for melted butter because the texture of the lobster was so dry and tough. They gave me a free desert since it was m... read more

deebles 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

Sampler and Buffalo Burger – We had high hopes based on the smells coming from the restaurant so we went in. It was mid -afternoon and they were not busy, however everything took longer than we would have expected. We waited about 10 minutes for a waiter who had no personality and made us feel like we were imposing. We orderd sweet tea. About 5 minutes later our tea and their specialty bread came to the table. That was the best part of the meal. 15 minutes later our waiter showed up and we ordered. We decided to be adventuro... read more

mamashow 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

Won't ever go back! – I agree with the other reviews, overpriced, rushed, and poor food. We went with our two children and decided to pay the prices and pretend to be on vacation. The waiter was rushing us so much that when he asked - for the fifth time - if we were ready to order and I told him "NO", he actually asked if I was having a problem with the menu and if he could help me decide. The food was cold and the experience left us feeling like we needed to go to another place to eat. 

cowpower 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

Disappointing – I went with my wife and daughter about a month after it opened. We were looking forward to the experience and when we walked in we were blown away by the breath-taking fish tank and fish mounted on the walls. It was fairly early and we were seated immediately. They sat us right next to the kitchen entrance and it was miserable, people were constantly walking past and knocking into our table. We also felt extremely rushed, we barely got our menu when the waitress asked for our order; we told her we needed more... read more

cherylann2 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

To Pricey for what you get! – My husband and I along with our 3 children went there summer of 2007, we couldn't wait to slurge on ourselves and have a wonderful meal. We wanted to make it a nice experience for our kids. We were seated right away, and the seating was way to crowded, not kid friendly. The chairs were very uncomfortable. We ordered the seafood sampler appetizer, it looked so good, but when we got it, it was cold and the portion was very small. it tasted like freezer stuff thawed out. Not even enough for everyon... read more

dog13 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

good food – The food is good. The loaf of bread with the sugar top is also good. The servers need much improvement. 

Contributor 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

Editorial Review – Enjoy fresh seafood from the Keys at this restaurant and bar located within the Bass Pro Shops at La Cantera.