Hero Beach Club

Kristen and Matt Todd 

on Google

2 months ago

I will start by saying we had a 5/5 experience. However, I would not say this is a 4 star hotel- closer to a 3 but a very lovely 3! There is definitely some maintenance/upkeep needed. Our bathroom light was flickering, bathroom hooks falling out of the wall. Some paint touch ups needed, etc. the bean bags (while ridiculously comfortable) smelled of mildew. We also had an issue with noise from the neighboring hotel room just after 11 pm- not a huge problem but it did raise the concern of who to contact at this hour as there w... read more

Lauren Davidowitz 

on Google

2 months ago

Super cute boho-chic vibe, friendly staff, and a lovely courtyard. Easy walk to the beach, nice complimentary drink, and I’d definitely stay here again! 

Natalie Acopian 

on Google

3 months ago

We have been staying at Hero Beach Club every summer since 2017 when the hotel opened. I booked a stay this August over the phone, paid in full, and received an email confirmation with the agreed price. I was told we would need to change rooms after the first night over the phone, which was fine, and this was confirmed upon check-in. When we arrived at the hotel, no one was at the front desk for about 15 minutes. Eventually, we checked into our first-floor room. The noise from upstairs was very loud — we could hear every sin... read more

Desi Oakley 

on Google

3 months ago

our favorite gem in Montauk — we’ve come back every summer for years!! quaint, laid-back luxury, steps from the perfect stretch of beach and a well-maintained pool. feels exclusive because of the small amount of rooms. bikes, beach loungers, towels: everything you need for a perfect summer escape! 

Stefanie Saulon 

on Google

3 months ago

I had an amazing experience here with my family, including my husband and our little toddler. This place was truly remarkable and a great stay to celebrate our wedding anniversary ! My son enjoyed the pool so much, and the hotel had a wonderful, laid-back vibe. Our room was stunning, offering ocean views and was the best in the hotel! It had a private balcony. I loved the room amenities and the complimentary drink we got upon check-in. They even set up beanbags and umbrellas at the beach, which was a nice touch. Tatiana was ... read more