Gemsmith Inc, Home of Ketti Jewelry

Shawn Brennan 

on Google

a month ago

Staff was extremely helpful/knowledgeable, I bought a ring from an antique shop(with limited information) they cleaned and checked it for me for free (and wouldn't take any money) and gave me the information on the ring that I needed.. im beyond pleased. I will be doing all of my jewlery purchases with them from now on.. thanks so much! 

Jason Santiago 

on Google

2 months ago

I brought a custom platinum engagement ring to Gem Smith in Ocean County for an appraisal in 2025. The ring was originally purchased from Jewelry Designs in Danbury, CT in 2018 for $14,250, plus tax ($15,354 total). The appraisal I received on 06/21/25 from Gem Smith valued the ring at $9,500 as a replacement cost — not resale. After fully reviewing the ring’s characteristics, this valuation is simply not realistic, and I believe it’s important to explain why to help others who have noted this discrepancy The ring features: ... read more

Erin Carroll 

on Google

2 months ago

After having some trouble finding somewhere to fit our needs, we came across Gemsmith, Inc. on Google. Today we went in to have some assorted gemstones identified & were sure we were just going to be told that they could not be of assistance, however, Kelley welcomed us to sit down & offered to take a look at what we brought in. She was incredibly kind, knowledgeable, & very patient as we asked a lot of questions. She spent a lot of time examining & testing our gemstones to give us the most accurate & informed information. W... read more

Jesse Samaritano 

on Google

2 months ago

Had an absolutely incredible experience with Ketti. I was given a diamond for the ring by my family, and Ketti designed and handmade the perfect band for the engagement ring. My fiancée is absolutely in love with the ring, Ketti really helped work with me to find a design that would be extra special to her within the budget given. I really could not recommend enough if you are looking for a standout engagement ring from a team that really knows their stuff!