Colonial Pizza

M Arnold 

on Google

10 years ago

When Tim ran/owned the place, it was perfect. It was the BEST in Cookeville. Under the new owners, the quality is way below standard as well as the quantity. We won't be going there ever again. 

Matthew Crawford 

on Google

11 years ago

I've known about this place for years, but only tried it last summer and I was hooked - not anymore. They used to have great pizza, but they've made some changes. Under previous owners, they had the best pizza in Cookeville, especially the chicken, bacon, ranch. Then it was sold to someone else at the first of this year. They stopped doing delivery, which is sad as it's the only place that delivered to my house, they also changed their sauce. It's been a few months since we had a pizza from this place, but last night we want... read more

jacob garrett 

on Google

11 years ago

Awesome. Just plain awesome. great food, from pizza to calazons to pinwheels to ceaser salads. By far my favorite place. True new york style pizza. If you swing by get a side of sausage added and your post will be next in order. 

Marc Peek 

on Google

13 years ago

Best slice in Cookeville. Do yourself a favor, take a break from the major chains and try some authentic Italian pizza. The shop is very unassuming, but this joint is one of this town's pizza lovers' best kept secrets.