Black Sheep Bagels Cutchogue

Cailey Yankowich 

on Google

3 weeks ago

Decided to give Black Sheep a try after hearing good things. I think the pictures speak for themselves, don’t go here! We called ahead and were told the order would take 30 minutes. Upon entering, we were told that we would need to go to the back of the line and wait (behind about 15 people). My question is what is the point of calling in an order if I need to wait amongst the people who haven’t even placed an order yet. By the time we got to the front of the line (an hour after placing our order over the phone), it wasn’t e... read more

Chris Ott 

on Google

a month ago

I was in a slightly rushed and negative mood this morning and stopped here for a quick bagel while passing by. I instantly felt better inside this place with the positive vibes, music and staff. I got a salt bagel with cream cheese and was so surprised to see salt flakes on it instead of the cheap NaCl chunks that most places use. I've never had actual salt on my salt bagel and it was fabulous. I'll definitely be going here again when I'm in this area.