Anthony's Pizza & Pasta

kate h. 

on Citysearch

13 years ago

DO NOT give any debit/credit information to this establishment!!! Someone who lived at an apartment I used to live at was able to order pizza's on my card using just the address as verification. When I complained to Anthony's they insisted that their employees verify the last four digits of the credit card and would not do anything for me. This is not the case as there is no way the new resident could know the last four digits of my card. 

YOUYOU 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

Worst pizza ever – I had a delivery, I was waiting for almost two hours. Food was cold, pizza was so greasy and oil was pooring out to the box, cardboard was oily, like soaked in oil, no taste no flavor at all. Please don't waste your money there 

ammcatee 

on Citysearch

14 years ago

Very Disappointed – I ordered a four topping slice for take out. The wait time was only five minutes. Upon opening the box, I could see why. It appeared that a slice of cheese pizza that had been cooked hours ago was loaded with raw toppings. When i folded it all the toppings fell off (since they were just thrown on without any cheese melted on top.) It wasn't warm or fresh. I will say they do give you quite a bit of toppings, but if they aren't even going to stay on the pizza, what is the point? I would have been happier wi... read more

gejones 

on Citysearch

15 years ago

Terrible Service – I must admit they make a good slice of pizza! However, every time I have been there the service and staff have been disappointing. Talk about unfriendly! ...I will not be back again. ...Too bad! 

Contributor 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

Locally owned pie purveyor serves up basic, budget-friendly pizzas and pastas. – In Short Local customers come here for standard-issue pizza. Clean booths and tables, walk-up counter service, self-serve drinks and plastic flatware. Pizzas come in thin- and thick-crust versions. Both are the fold-it-in-half, grease-dripping type so popular in the Big Apple. The eatery also serves up affordable plates of pasta, fresh Italian-style salads and daily specials that include calzones. Delivery can take over an hour, but the wait's u... read more

ufsteve 

on Citysearch

17 years ago

BEST PIZZA in the USA – My son and I ate at Anthony's on Iliff at Buckley on our way to skiing at Keystone. We consider ourselves "Pizza Connoisseurs", we only eat plain cheese pies. I grew up on Long Island in the 50s and 60s and thought I had gone back in time while eating a pie at Anthony's. It was great trying to keep the oils from running down my arm with each huge slice. I live in Florida now and there is no such thing as a good pizza pie in Florida. I thought my memories had been tainted by this, but I was on Long Isl... read more

prettyhot 

on Citysearch

18 years ago

The pizza isn't worth digesting – We had our pizza delivered. It was barely lukewarm. It was a low-quality pizza with low grade cheese and a bread dough crust that tasted like Pillsbury. Maybe worse. It is insulting they claim it is NY style pizza. Its not even close. The pizza was flavorless and the crust was disgusting. I will never eat here again. I cannot believe it was even featured on MetroBeat-whatever that Denver TV show is called. BAD BAD Pizza. 

Contributor 

on Citysearch

19 years ago

Locally owned pie purveyor serves up basic, budget-friendly pizzas and pastas. – In Short Local customers come here for standard-issue pizza. Clean booths and tables, walk-up counter service, self-serve drinks and plastic flatware. Pizzas come in thin- and thick-crust versions. Both are the fold-it-in-half, grease-dripping type so popular in the Big Apple. The eatery also serves up affordable plates of pasta, fresh Italian-style salads and daily specials that include calzones. Delivery can take over an hour, but the wait's u... read more

bisquick080 

on Citysearch

22 years ago

True New York Pizza – Walk in the door and what do you see? New York stuff everywhere mets, giants, jets, and of course yankees... What do you eat? Neopolitan slice, sicilian... What do you get? the best pizza in colorado along with down to earth employees... true to New York style pizza, the owners? from New York of course... listen to the accent...